Biological test method for measuring survival of springtails exposed to contaminants in soil: appendix F
Appendix F
Procedural Variations for Tests of Effects of Contaminated Soil on the Survival and Reproduction of Springtails, as Described in International Methodology Documents
Source documents are listed chronologically, by originating agency or by author(s).
W & K 1998 (Wiles and Krogh 1998) - this publication describes protocols for measuring survival, growth, and reproduction effects in three species of springtails including Folsomia candida (Willem, 1902), Isotoma viridis(Bourlet, 1839), and Folsomia fimetaria (Linné, 1758); published in 1998 in the “Handbook of Soil Invertebrate Toxicity Tests,” Løkke and van Gestel (eds.), West Sussex, England.
ISO 1999 - an international standard test method for measuring soil toxicity using a test for effects on reproduction of Folsomia candida, published in 1999 by the International Standard Organization in Geneva, Switzerland.
OECD 2005 - a draft proposal released by the National Environmental Research Institute in Denmark, to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), for a new test guideline that assesses the effects of chemical-spiked soils on the reproduction of two species of Collembola (Folsomia fimetariaand Folsomia candida); under consideration for publication by the OECD in Paris, France.
1. Test Species, Test Type, and Test Duration
Document | Species | Test Type | Test Duration |
---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 | Folsomia candida(Willem, 1902) | static-renewalFootnote1 | 8 weeksFootnote2 |
W & K 1998 | Isotoma viridis(Bourlet, 1839) | static-renewalFootnote1 | 8 weeks |
W & K 1998 | Folsomia fimetaria (Linné, 1758) | static | 3 weeks |
ISO 1999 | Folsomia candida(Willem, 1902) | static | 28 days |
OECD 2005 | Folsomia fimetaria (Linné, 1758) | static | 3 weeks |
OECD 2005 | Folsomia candida(Willem, 1902) | static | 4 weeks |
2. Specifics on Test Organisms at Start
Document | Description of Organisms Used to Start Test | Acclimation Conditions | Age of Organisms at Test Start |
---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida | cultured juveniles, age-synchronized | NIFootnote3 | 10 to 12 days |
W & K 1998 I. viridis | cultured juveniles, age-synchronized | NI | 5 to 7 days |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | cultured juveniles, age-synchronized | NI | 23 to 26 days |
ISO 1999 | cultured juveniles, age-synchronized | NI | 10 to 12 days |
OECD 2005 | cultured adults, age-synchronized | NI | adults |
3. Test Vessels and Materials
Document | Test Vessel | Cover | Type of Test SoilFootnote4 | Amount of Soil/Container |
---|---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida | 5 × 2 cm glass tubes, closed tightly | tight fitting lid | AS, StS | 4 ± 0.1 g per tube, dry wt (~5 g wet wt) |
W & K 1998 I. viridis | 5 × 2.5 cm glass tubes, closed tightly | tight fitting lid | AS, StS | 4 ± 0.1 g per tube, dry wt (~5 g wet wt)Footnote5 |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | cylinder; 6 cm in diameter, 5.5 cm high; 1 mm mesh bottom; closed | lids at top and bottom | AS, StS | 30 g per container, wet wt |
ISO 1999 | 100 mL glass container; 5 cm in diameter; closed tightly | plastic or glass disk, or parafilm | AS | 30 g per container, wet wt |
OECD 2005 | partly transparent; transparent lids which reduce water evaporation but allow gas exchange | glass or inert plastic | AS, StS | amount corresponding to 25 g dry wt; 3-4 cm deep |
4. Description of Test Soils, Including Composition of Artificial Soil
Document | Description of Test Soil(s) | Composition of Artificial SoilFootnote6 |
---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida | standard soilFootnote7 with added test substance (e.g., chemical in deionized water or organic solvent; if insoluble, test substance mixed in fine quartz sand)Footnote8 and distilled or deionized water | 10% sphagnum peat,Footnote9 20% kaolinite clay with ≥ 30% kaolinite, and 70% industrial sand with > 50% particles 50-200 μm adjust to pH 6.0 ± 0.5 using CaCO3, |
W & K 1998 I. viridis | standard soilFootnote7, Footnote10with added test substance (e.g., chemical in deionized water or organic solvent; if insoluble, test substance mixed in fine quartz sand)3 and distilled or deionized water | 10% sphagnum peat,Footnote9 20% kaolinite clay with ≥ 30% kaolinite, and 70% industrial sand with > 50% particles 50-200 μm, adjust to pH 6.0 ± 0.5 using CaCO3 |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | standard soilFootnote7 with added test substance (e.g., chemical in deionized water or organic solvent; if insoluble, test substance mixed in fine quartz sand)Footnote8 and distilled or deionized water | 10% sphagnum peat,Footnote12 20% kaolinite clay with ≥ 30% kaolinite, and 70% industrial sand with > 50% particles 50-200 μm, adjust to pH .0 ± 0.5 using CaCO3 |
ISO 1999 | artificial soil with added test substance (e.g., chemical in deionized water or organic solvent; if insoluble, test substance mixed in fine quartz sand)Footnote11 | 10% sphagnum peat,Footnote12 20% kaolinite clay with ≥ 30% kaolinite, and 70% ndustrial sand with > 50% particles 50-2003μm, adjust to pH 6.0 ± 0.5 using CaCO3 |
OECD 2005 | artificial soil or standard soilFootnote13 with added test substances (e.g., chemical in de-ionized waterFootnote14 or in organic solvent; if insoluble, test substance is mixed with fine quartz sandFootnote15 | 5 or 10% sphagnum peat,Footnote16 20% kaolin clay with > 30% kaolinite, and 69-70%Footnote17 air- dried industrial sand with > 50% particles 50-2003μm, adjust to pH 6.0 ± 0.5 using CaCO3 |
5. Manipulation of Artificial Soil Before Use in Test
Document | Mixing | Hydration | pH Adjustment |
---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida | blend dry constituents in correct proportions and mix with some deionized water; hydrate | hydrate to crumbly structure; normally to 40-60% of total water-holding capacity | none when acidic or basic substances are tested |
W & K 1998 I. viridis | blend dry constituents in correct proportions and mix with some deionized water; hydrate | hydrate to crumbly structure; normally to 40-60% of total water-holding capacity | none when acidic or basic substances are tested |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | blend dry constituents in correct proportions and mix with some deionized or distilled water; hydrate | hydrate to porous soil texture one week before initiating test | none when acidic or basic substances are tested |
ISO 1999 | blend dry constituents in correct proportions and mix with some deionized water; hydrate | hydrate to crumbly structure; normally to 40-60% of total water-holding capacityFootnote18 | NIFootnote19 |
OECD 2005 | blend dry constituentsFootnote20 | hydrate to ~50% of the maximum water-holding capacityFootnote21 (corresponding to 50 ± 10% moisture dry mass) moisture content should be optimized to loose porous texture | NI |
6. Negative Control Soil
Document | Description of Negative Control Soil | Number of Control Vessels (replicates) |
---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida | prepare in the same way as that for test soils, but without the test substance; use additional controls if auxillary substances other than water are used to dissolve test substance (e.g., organic solvent, quartz sand) | ≥ 3 |
W & K 1998 I. viridis | prepare in the same way as that for test soils, but without the test substance; use additional controls if auxillary substances other than water are used to dissolve test substance (e.g., organic solvent, quartz sand) | ≥ 3 |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | prepare in the same way as that for test soils, but without the test substance; use additional controls if auxillary substances other than water are used to dissolve test substance (e.g., organic solvent, quartz sand) | ≥ 4 |
ISO 1999 | prepare in the same way as that for test soils, but without the test substance; use additional controls if auxillary substances other than water are used to dissolve test substance (e.g., organic solvent, quartz sand) | 5 |
OECD 2005 | prepare in the same way as for test soils, but without the test substance; apply organic solvents, quartz sand or other vehicles to additional controls in amounts consistent with those used in treatments | ≥ 4 |
7. Storage and Characterization of Test Soil
Document | Storage Conditions | Soil CharacterizationFootnote22 |
---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida |
store mixed test soils in closed glass vessels at 15°C until required | moisture content and pH after hydrating |
W & K 1998 I. viridis |
store mixed test soils in closed glass vessels at 15°C until required | moisture content and pH after hydrating |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria |
NIFootnote23 | moisture content and pH after hydrating |
ISO 1999 | NI, NAFootnote24 | moisture content and pH after hydrating |
OECD 2005 | NI, NA | water-holding capacity and pH |
8. Preliminary Test - Number of Organisms per Vessel, Number of Replicates per Treatment, Number of Concentrations per Sample, and Recommended Dilution Factor
Document | Number of Organisms per Vessel | Number of Replicates per Treatment or Concentration | Number of Concentrations per Sample or Test Material | Recommended Dilution Factor |
---|---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candidaFootnote25, Footnote26 |
10 | NIFootnote27 | 5 | geometric seriesFootnote28 |
W & K 1998 I. viridisFootnote25, Footnote26 |
20 | NI | 5 | geometric seriesFootnote28 |
W & K 1998 F. fimetariaFootnote25, Footnote29 |
20Footnote 3030 | 1 | 4 + control | geometric seriesFootnote 3131 |
ISO 1999Footnote25, Footnote 3232 | 10 | 1 | 4 + control | geometric seriesFootnote 3131 |
OECD 2005Footnote25, Footnote 3333 F. fimetaria | 20Footnote 3030 | 2 | 5 + control | geometric seriesFootnote 3434 |
OECD 2005Footnote25, Footnote 3333 F. candida | 10 | 2 | 5 + control | geometric seriesFootnote 3434 |
9. Definitive Test - Number of Organisms per Vessel, Number of Replicates per Treatment, Number of Concentrations per Sample, and Recommended Dilution Factor
Document | Number of Organisms per Vessel | Number of Replicates per Treatment or Concentration | Number of Concentrations per Sample or Test Material | Recommended Dilution Factor |
---|---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida |
10 | ≥ 3 | ≥ 5 + control | NIFootnote 3535, Footnote 3636 |
W & K 1998 I. viridis |
20 | ≥ 3 | ≥ 5 + control | NIFootnote 3636, Footnote 3737 |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | 20Footnote 3838 | ≥ 4 | NI | NI Footnote 3939, Footnote 4040 |
ISO 1999Footnote 4141 | 10 | for NOEC: 5 | ≥ 5 + control | geometric seriesFootnote 4242 |
for ECx: ≥ 2 for treatments and 5 for controls | 12 + control | geometric seriesFootnote 4343 | ||
OECD 2005 F. fimetaria | 20Footnote 3838 | ≥ 4 | NI | NI Footnote 3939, Footnote 4040 |
OECD 2005 F. candida | 10 | ≥ 4 | ≥ 4 + controlFootnote 4444 | NIFootnote 3535, Footnote 4545 |
10. Feeding and Aeration During Test
Document | Type of Food Recommended | Feeding Quantity, Procedure, and Frequency | Aeration of Test Vessels |
---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida |
granules of baker’s yeast | add 3 granules to each test tube at the start of the test and at each weekly transferral | NIFootnote 4646 |
W & K 1998 I. viridis |
granules of baker’s yeast | add 3 granules to each test tube at the start of the test and at each weekly transferral | NI |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria |
dried baker’s yeast | add 15 mg at the beginning of the test and after 14 days | NI |
ISO 1999 | granulated dry yeast | add ~2 mg of granulated dry yeast to each test vessel at the beginning of the test and after a period of 14 days; cover vessels tightly after feeding | test containers are opened briefly two times per week to allow for aeration |
OECD 2005 | granulated dry baker’s yeast | add 15 mg at the beginning of the test and after each 14-day interval | NI |
11. Temperature and Lighting During Test
Document | Temperature (°C) | Lighting ConditionsFootnote 4747 |
---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida | 15 ± 0.5 | 12h L:12h D or 16h L:8h D; intensity <1000 lux |
W & K 1998 I. viridis | 15 ± 0.5Footnote 4848 | 16h L:8h D; intensity <1000 lux |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | 20 ± 1 | 12h L:12h D; intensity 400-800 lux |
ISO 1999 | 20 ± 2 | 12h L:12h D or 16h L:8h D; intensity 400-800 lux at substrate surface |
OECD 2005 | 20 ± 2 | 16h L:8h D preferred; intensity of 400-800 lux in the area of the test vessels |
12. Measurements and Biological Observations During Test
Document | MeasurementsFootnote 4949 | Biological Observations |
---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida | W and pH, each treatment, at start and end of test Footnote 5050, Footnote 5151 | number of live adults per test vessel, measurements of individual body lengths of surviving adults,Footnote 5252and number of juveniles hatching from eggs collected from soilFootnote 5353weekly and at the end of the test |
W & K 1998 I. viridis | W and pH, each treatment at start and end of testFootnote 5050, Footnote 5151 | number of live adults per test vessel, measurements of individual body lengths of surviving adults,Footnote 5252weekly and at the end of the test |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria | W and pH at start and end of testFootnote 5151, Footnote 5454 | number of live adults per test vessel, number of offspring per test container at the end of the test |
ISO 1999 | W and pH, each treatment, at start and end of test; reweigh test containers periodically throughout testFootnote 5555, Footnote 5656 | number of live adult and juvenile springtails per test vessel at the end of the exposure |
OECD 2005 | W and pHFootnote 5757 each treatment at start and end of test; weight of test vessels at start and weekly thereafterFootnote 5858 |
13. Terminating Test, Biological Endpoints, and Statistical Endpoints
Document | Terminating Test | Biological Endpoints | Statistical Endpoints |
---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida |
Collembola are extracted from soil in the tubes at weekly intervals during the exposure and at the end of the test; the soil from each tube is put into a larger vessel and Collembola are collected with a hand-held air aspirator | mean percent survival, mean body size of individuals, and mean number of juveniles produced at each concentration and each assessment interval | EC10 and EC50 for growth and reproduction (mg/kg dry wt of soil) |
W & K 1998 I. viridis |
Collembola are extracted from soil in the tubes at weekly intervals during the exposure and at the end of the test; the soil from each tube is put into a larger vessel and Collembola are collected with a hand-held air aspirator | mean percent survival and mean body size of individuals produced at each concentration and each assessment interval | EC10 and EC50 for growth (mg/kg dry wt of soil) |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria |
At the end of 3 weeks, the organisms are extracted from each test container with a high gradient extractorFootnote 5959 | mortality, percent loss or increase of adult biomass, and number of offspring produced | EC10, EC50, and LC50 for chronic mortality and growth (mg/kg dry wt of soil) |
ISO 1999 | 4 weeks after introducing parental springtails onto the test and control substrates, the test substrate is poured into a 500-600 mL container and water is added; the suspension is gently stirred;the adults and juveniles floating on the water surface are countedFootnote 6060 | mean number of adults and juveniles for each concentration; percent mortality of adults per concentration; mean number of offspring produced for each concentration after 28 days | NOEC and ECxFootnote 6161 |
OECD 2005 | Collembola are extracted from soil with a high gradient heat extractor1 offspring produced or by floatationFootnote 6262 | mortality and number of offsprings produced | LC50, ECx, and NOEC |
14. Requirements for Valid Test; Use of Reference Toxicity Test
Document | Requirements for Valid Test | Reference Toxicant(s) | Procedures and Conditions for Reference Toxicity Test |
---|---|---|---|
W & K 1998 F. candida |
≥ 10 juveniles/surviving parental adult in control soil each week; percent mortality of adults in control(s) < 20% | none recommended at present | NIFootnote 6666 |
W & K 1998 I. viridis |
percent mortality of adults in control(s) < 50% | none recommended at present | NI |
W & K 1998 F. fimetaria |
> 200 juveniles/control vessel; percent mortality of adults in control(s) < 20% | dimethoateFootnote 6363 and reproduction | determine effects on survival |
ISO 1999 | ≥ 100 instars/control vessel; CV for control reproduction ≤ 30%; percent mortality of adults in control(s) ≤ 20% | Betanal plus; and E 605 forteFootnote 6464, Footnote 6565 | determine effects on survival and reproduction once or twice per year |
OECD 2005 F. fimetaria | > 200 juveniles/control vessel; percent mortality of adults in control(s) < 20%; CV of juveniles in controls < 25% | to be determined | determine effects on survival and reproduction |
OECD 2005 F. candida | ≥ 100 juveniles/control vessel; percent mortality of adults in control(s) < 20%; CV of juveniles in controls < 25% | to be determined | determine effects on survival and reproduction |
Page details
- Date modified: