CIMM – Committee & Appearance Overview – March 24, 2022
About the Committee
Mandate
The Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration (CIMM) studies matters related to immigration, citizenship and federal multiculturalism policy.
The committee has oversight of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada and the Immigration and Refugee Board.
Studies
The committee has moved to undertake three studies this session. The first and current study is on Recruitment and Acceptance Rates of Foreign Students, which included a ministerial appearance. This is expected to be followed by studies on Differential Outcomes and Application Backlogs and Processing Times.
Reports
The committee has presented the following reports this session:
- Report 1 – Safe Haven in Canada: Special Immigration and Refugee Measures are Urgently Needed for the People of Hong Kong (re-tabled from previous session)
- Report 2 – Immigration in the Time of Covid-19: Issues and Challenges (re-tabled from previous session)
- Report 3 – Situation at the Russia-Ukraine Border
- Report 4 – Supplementary Estimates (C)
About the Appearance
Background
On February 1, 2022, the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration (CIMM) adopted the following motion inviting the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship to appear on their study on Differential Outcomes on March 24, 2022:
That the Committee conduct a study on systemic discrimination that leads to differential outcomes in Immigration Refugee and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) decisions based on factors such as race and region, examine the factors used to assess the genuineness of a relationship for family sponsorships; that the committee explore the allegations of racism and discrimination included in the Pollara Strategic Insights final report on the IRCC Anti-Racism Employee Focus Groups; that the committee examine the scope and impact of the use of advanced analytics technology in the application process.
The following officials will accompany the Minister for the first hour, and remain for the second hour to continue addressing committee questions. The Minister is expected to deliver a 5-minute opening statement.
- Caroline Xavier, Associate Deputy Minister
- Pemi Gill, Director General, International Network
- Farah Boisclair, Director, Anti-Racism Task Force
Environmental scan
The Minister, along with departmental officials, will have appeared at CIMM three times prior to this appearance. It is anticipated that the study on Differential Outcomes will closely analyze the potential systemic bias that exists within IRCC, and its influence on decision making and mitigation strategies. Key lines of questioning based on topics of interest to date have included:
- The IRCC Anti-Racism report by Pollara Strategic Insights
- Acceptance and refusal rates of foreign students, both within Quebec and outside of Quebec
- The Chinook tool and artificial intelligence
- Third-party oversight by means of an Ombudsman
- Student Direct Stream, and the disparity caused by some countries having this option while others do not.
Committee Membership
- Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe (Lac-Saint-Jean)
- Critic for Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship and Human Rights; Second Vice-Chair of CIMM; Vice-Chair of AFGH
- Jenny Kwan (Vancouver East, BC)
- Long-standing Critic for Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship; recently appointed as Critic for Housing; Vice-Chair of AFGH
- Jasraj Singh Hallan (Calgary Forest Lawn, AB)
- Returning Shadow Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship; Member of AFGH
- Garnett Genuis (Sherwood Park–Fort Saskachewan, AB)
- Bob Benzen (Calgary Heritage, AB)
- Brad Redekopp (Saskatoon West, SK)
- Deputy Shadow Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship
- Salma Zahid (Scarborough Centre, ON)
- Re-elected Chair of CIMM; Member of AFGH
- Marie-France Lalonde (Orléans, ON)
- Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship
- Sukh Daliwal (Surrey–Newton, BC)
- Chair of AFGH
- Shafqat Ali (Brampton Centre, ON)
- Fayçal El-Khoury (Laval—Les Îles, QC)
- Member for AFGH
- Arielle Kayabaga (London West, ON)
Conservative Party of Canada
Top Party Issues
The CPC is calling on the government to lift visa requirements for Ukrainians hoping to flee to Canada. The party has frequently drawn unfavourable parallels between Afghanistan and Ukraine in their messaging.
The party has increased its focus on issues of racism and discrimination at IRCC, with questions often centering around accountability and action being taken in response to the Pollara Report.
Processing delays and backlogs have been at the forefront of questioning. Their platform recommends implementing an express processing fee, moving immigration infrastructure online, and recording all officer-applicant interactions.
The CPC often raise the issue of Canada’s skilled labour shortage and the role of immigration and migrant workers in the economy.
The integrity of the immigration system, particularly as it relates to data breaches, safety and security, have been highly discussed, including alleged breaches of Afghan refugee data and issues of foreign interference.
On family reunification, the party mainly focuses on processing times. Their platform recommends eliminating the lottery system, and combining FIFO and weighting principles.
On refugees, the party believes that the Government Assisted Refugees stream should be terminated, that a human rights defenders stream should be implemented, and that the Residential Rehabilitation Assistance Program should be made permanent.
The party has advocated for changes to border and asylum, including closing the Safe Third Country Agreement loophole and expediting Immigration and Refugee Board asylum hearings.
Recent Party Activity
- Mar 3 – CIMM: Raised concerns that the government was treating the evacuation of Afghans differently than Ukrainians (Hallan).
- Mar 2 – LANG: Suggested that alleged disparities in francophone student acceptance rates are rooted in racism (Godin).
- Feb 28 – Debates: Characterized the “Liberal immigration system” as racist, pointed to allegations IRCC use the term “dirty thirty,” to francophone African student rejection rates and to the Pollara report as evidence (Hallan).
- Feb 17 – CIMM: Claimed there was an “undertone” of racism and discrimination at IRCC, pointed to francophone student acceptance rates as evidence (Hallan).
- Feb 16 – CIMM: Requested information on anti-racism efforts underway at IRCC (Hallan).
- Feb 15 – CIMM: Asked for the status of IRCC’s anti-racism response report (Hallan).
- Feb 16 – Q-348: Refusal of applications submitted to IRCC (Hallan).
- Feb 16 – Q-349: Applications for the resettlement of refugees from Afghanistan (Hallan).
- Feb 16 – Q-350: Information on the Chinook Tool (Hallan).
- Feb 10 – Twitter: Shared a National Post article discussing “leaked” communications between Liberal MP and government officials, in which Powlowski lobbied for measures to evacuate CAF interpreters from Afghanistan (Hallan).
- Feb 7 – Oral Questions: Inquired about processing backlogs (Hallan).
- Feb 7 – Q-316: Chinook Tool keywords (Redekopp).
- Feb 4 – Q-310: Evacuation of CAF interpreters from Afghanistan (Kusie).
- Jan 31 – Q-298: Backlogs in applications for Permanent Residency (Seeback).
- Jan 28 – Twitter: Stated that the recent announcement on pausing the intake on highly skilled immigrant workers is harmful to the economy and causing our trades to suffer (Hallan).
Cimm Members
- Jasraj Singh Hallan (Calgary Forest Lawn, AB)
- Returning Shadow Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship; former Shadow Minister of Multiculturalism; Vice-Chair of AFGH
- Topics of interest
- Processing times and backlogs
- Access to information and data breaches
- Canada’s response to Afghanistan, focus on interpreters, evacuations, refugee measures, and protecting persecuted religious and other minorities
- Racism and discrimination
- Immigration pathways for all skill levels, temporary foreign workers and international students
- Public safety and security
- Parents and Grandparents processing times
- Garnett Genuis (Sherwood Park–Fort Saskachewan, AB)
- Bob Benzen (Calgary Heritage,AB)
- Brad Redekopp(Saskatoon West, SK)
- Deputy Shadow Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship
Other Active Members
- Raquel Dancho (Kildonan—St. Paul, MB)
- Shadow Minister for Public Safety; former Shadow Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship
- Matt Jeneroux (Edmonton Riverbend, AB)
- Shadow Minister for Housing and Diversity and Inclusion
- Garnett Genuis (Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan,AB)
- Active on immigration and security issues pertaining to Hong Kong
- Pierre Paul-Hus (Charlesbourg—Haute-Saint-Charles, QC)
- Shadow Minister for Public Services and Procurement
- Michael D. Chong (Wellington—Halton Hills)
- Vice-Chair of AFGH
New Democratic Party
Top Party Issues
The NDP calls for the appointment of an immigration Ombudsperson to provide independent oversight over IRCC in response to reports of security breaches and alleged racism within the department.
On Afghanistan, the party has criticised the government for inaction and called for a need to do more in response to the humanitarian crisis, particularly for those at most risk who are inside their source country. They also seek to relax requirements for Afghan refugees to come to Canada.
Ukraine has recently become a focus for the party, with the NDP calling for the government to lift visa requirements for Ukrainians seeking a safe haven in Canada. NDP members have frequently compared the situation in Ukraine to Afghanistan.
On economic immigration, the party often advocates for aligning immigration levels with labour force needs. They call on the government to bring back an economic program for all skill levels.
Providing permanent residence upon arrival is a key recommendation put forth by the party as a means to reduce the precarious status of migrant workers.
The party often intervenes on issues of migrant worker rights and safety, has called for expanding on healthcare, and for terminating both the Live-In Caregiver Program and Temporary Foreign Worker Program. They also advocate for removing language requirements in permanent residence applications.
On family reunification, the elimination of the lottery system and of caps to sponsoring parents and grandparents is a top issue, as is the reduction of backlogs in this line of business. The party has advocated for broadening the definition of family to include extended family.
With regard to refugees, a permanent resettlement program for LGBTI refugees is a frequent request by the party.
Recent Party Activity
- Mar 10 – Twitter: Retweeted a CBC News article about racism amongst IRCC staff (Kwan).
- Mar 7 – NDP.ca: The NDP is asking the government to offer expedited access to Canada to refugees in Ukraine who are especially vulnerable due to systemic discrimination (Singh).
- Mar 4 – Oral Questions: Claimed that Afghan refugees fleeing the situation in Ukraine were being subjected to racial discrimination (Kwan).
- Feb 17 – CIMM: Pointed to differences between the Student Direct Stream and the Nigerian Express Program in the context of racism and discrimination at IRCC (Kwan).
- Feb 15 – Oral Questions: Asked for further government action on the evacuation of interpreters and refugees from Afghanistan (Kwan).
- Feb 15 – News Release: The NDP issued a news release calling on the government to take immediate action to help Afghan refugees (Kwan) (McPherson).
- Feb 8 – CIMM: Discussed racism at IRCC, AI and discrimination, and third party oversight at IRCC. Asked a witness to submit a copy their ATIP request regarding discrimination and foreign student acceptance rates to the committee so that the Chair may convey it to officials (Kwan).
- Feb 3 – CIMM: Inquired about the statistics related to applications assessed by the Chinook tool, as well as the risk words used to flag applications (Kwan).
- Feb 1 – CIMM: Inquired about statistics and the breakdown of the rejection rates as it relates to international and francophone students (Kwan).
- Jan 31 – Hill Times: Commented on long processing times, not only for Afghan asylum seekers, but also all of IRCC’s clients (Kwan).
- Jan 28 – Radio-Canada: Stated that racism has no place in society and the government has an obligation to lead by example and ensure their policies are not discriminatory (Kwan).
- Nov 3 – Letter to the Minister: Various IRCC concerns: departmental capacity, processing times and backlogs; need for greater transparency; recommending an Immigration Ombudsman, permanent residence on arrival for migrant workers to prevent precariousness; more action for Afghanistan and Hong Kong; asylum processing; withdraw from Safe Third Country Agreement (Kwan).
Cimm Member
- Jenny Kwan (Vancouver East, BC)
- Long-standing Critic for Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship; recently appointed as Critic for Housing; Vice-Chair of AFGH
- Topics of interest
- Creating an Immigration Ombudsman
- Measures for Afghanistan and Hong Kong
- Adequate housing availability and affordability
- Processing capacity and backlogs
- Permanent residence on arrival for migrant workers
- Rights, safety and precariousness of Caregivers and other migrant workers
- Extending the definition of family for reunification
- Withdrawal from the Safe Third Country Agreement and Roxham Road
- Privacy concerns and transparency
- Parents and Grandparents lottery system
- Humanitarian and compassionate refusals
Other Active Members
- Blake Desjarlais (Edmonton Griesbach, AB)
- Deputy Critic Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship; Critic Diversity and inclusion; Deputy Critic 2SLGBTQI+ rights
- Alastair MacGregor (Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, BC)
- Critic Public Safety; Critic Agriculture and Food
- Heather McPherson (Edmonton Strathcona, AB)
- Deputy Whip; Critic Foreign Affairs and International Development
Bloc Québécois
Top Party Issues
Quebec’s interests and the protection of the French language are at the forefront of party interventions. Francophone immigration is a top interest, and the party has proposed settlement incentives for Quebec (e.g. tax credits). The BQ has recently focused on acceptance rates of international students from African countries.
The party has proposed changes to the Temporary Foreign Worker Program including a transfer of the program to Quebec, a halt in annual LMIAs, and an increase on work permit and visa duration. They call for improvements to processing times in the agriculture sector and stress the crucial role of migrant workers in food security.
On economic immigration, the party advocates for digitizing and expediting the processing of Quebec permanent resident applications. They previously called on the government to exempt Confirmation of Permanent Residence holders from travel restrictions.
With regard to borders and asylum, the party calls for increasing Quebec border management powers, and ending the Safe Third Country Agreement as a means to stop irregular migration.
On family reunification, the party calls for a transfer of the program to Quebec.
In the 43rd Parliament, the party was a strong advocate for guardian angels.
Recent Party Activity
- Feb 28 – LANG: Claimed to have experienced racism through IRCC Montreal offices hiring unilingual English positions, suggested there may be “francophobia” at IRCC (Beaulieu).
- Feb 23 – Qub.ca: Suggested francophones were discriminated against through Canadian immigration practices (Brunelle-Duceppe).
- Feb 17 – Twitter: Shared a Radio-Canada article about SADM Campbell Jarvis’s remarks at CIMM committee regarding the risk of discrimination in AI (Brunelle-Duceppe).
- Feb 11 – Twitter: Accused IRCC of neglecting the French language (Bloc Québécois).
- Feb 9 – Twitter: Shared a Journal of Montreal article about Francophone Immigration, criticized the Minister for not granting an interview (Brunelle-Duceppe).
- Feb 8 – CIMM: Suggested racism and discrimination was at play in acceptance rates of international students, voiced support for third party oversight of IRCC, focused on acceptance rates from Francophone countries (Brunelle-Duceppe).
- Feb 3 – CIMM: Inquired about the Chinook Tool and inequity (Brunelle-Duceppe).
- Feb 1 – Twitter: Shared and commented on a Journal of Montreal article on the Minister not making a recent announcement in French (Blanchet).
- Jan 31 – AFGH: Inquired about immigration from Afghanistan (Brunelle-Duceppe).
- Jan 28 – Twitter: Shared an article from Radio-Canada on the plight of French-speaking African students and suggested the government had taken no action on the issue (Normandin).
- Jan 28 – Radio-Canada: Stated that he believes that these students are subjected to discrimination and said he is looking forward to hearing the Minister’s opinion on the matter (Brunelle-Duceppe).
- Jan 28 – Twitter: Shared a Radio-Canada article discussing the high refusal rates for francophone international students from Africa and commented on systemic racism at IRCC (Blanchet, Villemure).
- Dec 1 – Oral Questions: Accusation of system discrimination underlying high rejection rates of francophone African students who want to come to Quebec (Blanchet).
- Nov 30 – Q-125: The use of the Chinook tool for processing of study permits and temporary visas, including cybersecurity and operations (Brunelle-Duceppe).
Cimm Member
- Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe (Lac-Saint-Jean)
- Critic for Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship and Human Rights; Second Vice-Chair of CIMM; Vice-Chair of AFGH
- Topics of interest
- Francophone immigration, including international students from French-speaking countries in Africa
- Immigration measures for Afghanistan
- Taking a stand against China in relation to the Uyghur genocide
- Suspending the Safe Third Country Agreement and irregular migration at Roxham Road
- Quebec interests and protection of the French language
- Human rights conflicts
- Processing delays
- Family reunification
Other Active Members
- Christine Normandin (Saint-Jean, QC)
- Former Critic Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship; BQ Deputy House Leader
- Yves-François Blanchet (Beloil-Chambly, QC)
- BQ Party Leader
Liberal Party Of Canada
Top Party Issues
Party efforts are focused on achieving the Immigration Levels and they have committed to resettling 40,000 eligible Afghan refugees.
Transformation and digitization in various lines of business is actively highlighted by the party and pointed to as a solution for modernizing the immigration system.
The government committed to improving processing times, collecting evidence to improve various policies and programs. They frequently highlight the importance of immigration in Canada’s present and future.
Recent Party Activity
- Mar 3 – Statements by Members: Raised concerns about anti-Black racism and about the plight of refugees fleeing Ukraine and subject to racial discrimination (Atwin).
- Feb 17 – CIMM: Asked the Minister if racism was at play in the rejection rates of francophone African students (Kayabaga).
- Feb 8 – Canada.ca: Announced new online case status tracker for family class permanent residence applications (Fraser).
- Feb 8 – CIMM: Inquired about allegations of racism and discrimination at IRCC (Dhaliwal) and fraud (El-Khoury).
- Feb 3 – CIMM: Commented on dual intent (Ali), inquired about protecting international students (Dhaliwal), and inquired about the Chinook Tool (Ali).
- Jan 31 – CBC Politics: Announced that the $85 million will be used to plow through the backlogged applications by hiring new staff and announced that IRCC will be back on track by the end of this year (Fraser).
- Jan 28 – Radio-Canada: Defended IRCC stating that case agents are highly qualified and evaluate cases based on the same criteria
- Jan 17 – News Conference: Spoke about the investment of $85 million that was attributed to address backlogs and processing delays and the long term investment of digitizing the immigration system (Fraser).
- Dec 13 – Hill Times: Liberal MPs speak candidly about their disappointment with processing delays.
- Nov 30 – Address in Reply: Our economy’s vitality will depend on our ability to welcome new Canadians. The government is committed to streamlining the immigration process (Ferrada).
- Nov 30 – Address in Reply: Shared support for the government’s commitment to immigration as highlighted in the Speech from the Throne (Aldag, Thompson).
- Nov 23 – Speech from the Throne: Commitment to increasing immigration levels and reducing wait times.
Cimm Members
- Salma Zahid (Scarborough Centre, ON)
- Re-elected Chair of CIMM; Member of AFGH
- Marie-France Lalonde (Orléans, ON)
- Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship
- Sukh Dhaliwal (Surrey–Newton, BC)
- Chair of AFGH
- Shafqat Ali (Brampton Centre, ON)
- Fayçal El-Khoury (Laval—Les Îles, QC)
- Member of AFGH
- Arielle Kayabaga (London West, ON)
Page details
- Date modified: