Procurement

Equipping the Canadian Armed Forces

  • People are at the core of everything the Canadian Armed Forces does to deliver on its mandate.
  • That is why, ensuring that our soldiers, sailors, and aviators are equipped with modern and effective equipment is a top priority for National Defence.
  • For example, I recently announced the first delivery of our new Armoured Combat Support Vehicles, made in London, Ontario.
  • The first four vehicles delivered are the ambulance variant, equipped for combat support, and additional ambulance variants will be delivered to bases across Canada in the coming months.
  • This marks the first of eight variants received by the Canadian Army, and deliveries of additional variants are expected next year.
  • Through the Armoured Combat Support Vehicle project, we are ensuring that members of the Canadian Army have the tools they need to conduct operations in Canada and abroad.
  • We will continue to make these types of investments into our people.
  • Earlier this year, we confirmed that Canada will procure the F-35A advanced fighter aircraft, representing the most significant investment in the Royal Canadian Air Force in more than 30 years.
  • For our deployed members on Op REASSURANCE, we are moving forward with three major procurements classified as Urgent Operational Requirements (UORs), which allows us to procure essential equipment on a sped-up timeline.
  • These procurements include the Portable Anti-X Missile (PAXM), Counter Uncrewed Aircraft Systems (CUAS) and an Air Defence System.
  • We will continue to make these types of investments so that our personnel in uniform are prepared and equipped to succeed on operations.

Key Facts

Armoured Combat Support Vehicles (ACSV)

  • Budget: $2 billion contract to General Dynamics Land Systems-Canada to procure 360 vehicles, initial spare parts, technical manuals, and training.
    • September 5, 2019 – Contract award to General Dynamics Land Systems-Canada
    • December 18, 2020 – First vehicle accepted
    • June 30, 2022 – Announcement of donation of 39 ACSVs to Ukraine
    • October 19. 2023 – First delivery of four ambulance variant ACSVs
    • 2024 – Initial operational capability
    • 2026 – Full operational capability

Urgent Operational Requirement (UOR)

  • Portable Anti-X Missile (PAXM)The PAXM systems include missiles, simulators, and associated support to empower CAF personnel deployed with the Canada-led multinational NATO enhanced Forward Presence Battle Group Latvia with training and the capability to destroy main battle tanks.
    • Request for Proposal (RFP) was issued in summer 2023, with a contract award expected before end of 2023.
    • Initial Operational Capability (IOC) is expected in early 2024; while Full Operational Capability (FOC) is expected by the end of 2024.
  • Air Defence (AD)The AD project will acquire a soldier portable Very-Short Range Air Defence System (VSHORAD) for the NATO enhanced Forward Presence Battle Group Latvia in order to defeat attack aircraft and hostile small unmanned aircraft its area of operations.
    • RFP was issued in Summer 2023.
    • Contract award is expected in early 2024.
  • Counter Uncrewed Aircraft Systems (CUAS) – The CUAS Project will provide protection measures against hostile small unmanned aircraft for CAF personnel deployed in the Operation REASSURANCE.
    • RFP was issued in Summer 2023.
    • IOC is expected in Fall 2024; while FOC is expected in Fall 2026.

Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships (AOPS)

  • Budget: Up to $4.98B (excluding taxes)
    • July 31, 2020: The first AOPS, HMCS Harry DeWolf, was delivered. 
    • July 15, 2021: The second AOPS, HMCS Margaret Brooke, was delivered.
    • August 15, 2022: Production of the sixth and final ship for the RCN began.
    • September 2, 2022: The third ship, HMCS Max Bernays, was delivered.
    • August 31, 2023: The fourth ship, HMCS William Hall, was delivered.
    • December 2024: Delivery target for fifth ship, the future HMCS Frédérick Rolette.
    • December 2025: Delivery target for sixth and final ship, the future HMCS Robert Hampton Gray.

Future Fighter Capability Project (FFCP)

  • Budget: $19 billion in acquisition funding was established in Strong, Secure, Engaged. This includes the aircraft, associated equipment, sustainment set-up and services, as well as the Fighter Squadron Facilities in Cold Lake, AB, and Bagotville, QC.
  • Delivery: The first aircraft will be delivered in 2026. The project will work with the F-35 Joint Program Office (JPO) through the project implementation phase to acquire additional F-35A fighter aircraft along with the associated equipment and services.
  • Initial Pilot Training: The initial 12 aircraft will be located at the F-35A Pilot Training Center in Luke Air Force Base, Arizona, to enable the training of RCAF pilots while DND builds the necessary infrastructure to support aircraft delivery and commence operations in Canada.

Details

Armoured Combat Support Vehicles

  • The Armoured Combat Support Vehicle (ACSV) will provide the Canadian Armed Forces with a new fleet of armoured and mobile vehicles to perform services such as ambulance, mobile repair and vehicle recovery services, as well as engineer support and command and control. These vehicles will be used for both domestic and international operations. 
  • 360 ACSVs will be procured through a $2 billion (taxes included) contract with General Dynamics Land Systems - Canada (GDLS-C).
  • The new fleet of 360 ACSVs will all be based on the LAV 6.0 and will replace the current Light Armoured Vehicle (LAV) II Bison and M113 Tracked LAV fleets.
  • Having our 360 support vehicles based on the same platform as the main combat vehicle fleet offers a number of key advantages from an operational and a sustainment perspective; for example, it will reduce training and sustainment costs, and result in an increased availability of spare parts to enable vehicles to be repaired quickly during critical operations.
  • With the Canadian Government donation of 39 ACSVs to Ukraine earlier this year, changes were introduced to the ACSV production schedule. Instead of receiving the Troop Cargo Vehicle (TCV) variant first, the Canadian Army took delivery of the first ambulance variants on October 19, 2023.
  • Plans by the Tracked Light Armoured Vehicles (TLAV) Equipment Management Team have also been developed to support the TLAV fleet slightly longer than previously planned, to account for the adjustments to the ACSV delivery schedule.
  • The ACSV fleet will be comprised of eight variants:
    • Troop/Cargo Vehicles (TCVs);
    • Ambulance (AMB) vehicles;
    • Command Post (CP) vehicles;
    • Electronic Warfare (EW) vehicles; 
    • Engineer (ENGR) vehicles;
    • Fitter/Cargo Vehicles (FCV);
    • Mobile Repair Team (MRT) vehicles;
    • Maintenance and Recovery Vehicles (MRVs).

Urgent Operational Requirement (UOR)

  • Urgent Operational Requirements (UOR) are a procurement mechanism that the Department of National Defence (DND) can use to procure essential equipment on a sped-up timeline.
  • The UOR mechanism meets a specific and urgent operational requirement, but it is not a new tool, nor is it a new initiative. This mechanism has historically been utilized to accelerate procurements associated with urgent Canadian Amed Forces (CAF) operational requirements, such as in Afghanistan, and we continue to utilize this process, when and where appropriate.
  • In response to the ongoing conflict in Ukraine, the Canadian Joint Operations Command has identified three UOR: a Portable Anti-X Missile (PAXM), portable soldier Air Defence (AD), and Counter Uncrewed Aircraft Systems (CUAS) to support members deployed in Eastern Europe as part of Operation REASSURANCE.

Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships

  • The AOPS will significantly enhance the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) capabilities and presence in the Arctic, better enabling the Royal Canadian Navy (RCN) to assert and uphold Canada’s Arctic sovereignty. The AOPS will also augment Canada’s presence on the Atlantic and Pacific oceans and will conduct a wide variety of operations abroad.
  • The AOPS will be able to operate in up to one meter of first-year ice, which is the ice condition experienced annually in the various waterways of the Canadian Arctic between June and October. Ice capability provided by the AOPS will provide a greater and longer CAF presence in the Canadian North.  

Future Fighter Capability Project

  • Project Details
    • The Future Fighter Capability Project (FFCP) will successfully acquire and transition into service 88 advanced fighter aircraft along with the associated equipment, weapons, infrastructure, information technology, and sustainment, including training and software support.
    • The process, led by Public Service and Procurement Canada, is overseen by an independent fairness monitor.
    • On January 9, 2023, Canada announced that it had finalized an agreement with the U.S. Government and Lockheed Martin with Pratt & Whitney for the acquisition of 88 F-35 fighter jets for the Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF). Delivery is expected to begin in 2026.
  • Economic Benefits
    • Canada has implemented a Value Proposition to motivate generational investments in our aerospace and defence industries over the coming decades, and to drive innovation, exports, and skills development in Canada’s Key Industrial Capabilities including In-Service Support, and Aerospace Systems and Components.

Defence Procurement Reform

  • Our Government continues to procure modernized equipment for the Canadian Armed Forces, such as six new Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships, an agreement to purchase 88 F-35A fighter aircraft, and new armoured combat support vehicles.
  • The successful and timely delivery of these capabilities requires a streamlined and flexible procurement system, especially due to the inflationary and supply chain impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • That is why we are working with our partners across Government to improve the speed at which we deliver capabilities while also ensuring economic benefits for Canadians.
  • For example, the PSPC-led Risk-based Approach to Contract Approval for low-risk defence projects has removed several check points throughout the procurement process, improving timeliness for the delivery of projects and capabilities.
  • We have applied this approach to a few procurements, such as the Heavy Weight Torpedo Upgrade, Naval Engineering Test Establishment, and Minor Warships and Auxiliary Vessels.
  • We also must work more collaboratively with our industry and Indigenous partners to ensure alignment and find realistic solutions and deliver capabilities on schedule. 
  • Specifically, we are working with partners on how we can move forward on sustaining operationally capable solutions for platforms.
  • This would mean providing National Defence with the flexibility required to rapidly integrate the latest technology upgrades over the in-service phase of a capability, to ensure platforms remain relevant and capable throughout their lifetime.
  • We have already seen this approach work effectively through our integrated soldier system project, which has seen three spirals of incremental capability releases to the CAF, and allows our members to influence each subsequent spiral over time.
  • Further, we are investing in our procurement professionals to make sure we have the expertise and capacity we need to advance projects.
  • While defence procurement can take time, we need to ensure it is done right as this equipment is vital to the defence of our country and Canada’s participation in international operations.

If pressed on staffing shortages of procurement specialists

  • Project management of complex defence procurement projects, such as fighter aircraft, surface combatants and NORAD modernization, requires skills that are built over many years.
  • National Defence manages hundreds of projects in various phases of the project life cycle, supported by a workforce of close to 1,000 project management personnel working towards delivery of capabilities.
  • To address increased demands for procurement expertise, the department is closely prioritizing and focusing efforts on the most critical capabilities and procurements, such as ammunition and urgent operational requirements.  
  • Growing the project management and procurement workforce continues to be a priority as we move forward on the delivery of critical capabilities to the Canadian Armed Forces.
  • As we take steps to grow and develop our procurement experts, we will ensure we offer a respectful, diverse, inclusive and supportive workplace.

Details

  • National Defence works closely with the CAF, partners in other federal government departments such as Public Services and Procurement Canada (PSPC) and Innovation, Science and Economic Development (ISED), as well as defence industry experts, to procure the equipment and services our Forces need.
  • We follow a rigorous project planning and procurement process that ensures the equipment procured meets all of the CAF requirements, while ensuring financial value for Canadians as well as economic growth for industry.
  • DND’s project management approach is governed by policy set by the Treasury Board of Canada, which states that:
    • projects achieve value for money;
    • sound stewardship of project funds is demonstrated;
    • accountability for project outcomes is transparent; and,
    • outcomes are achieved within time and cost constraints.

Streamlining Defence Procurement

  • National Defence has taken a number of concrete steps to ensure the members of the CAF get the equipment they need, when they need it, including:
    • Updating defence procurement program management processes by eliminating redundancies and improving collaboration with industry.
    • Accelerating procurement by eliminating certain requirements for low-risk, low-complexity projects.
    • Working closely with colleagues across government to implement more agile and innovative procurement approaches.
    • Investing in procurement professionals to make sure we have the expertise and capacity we need to advance projects.
    • Working with industry and other government partners on how we can move forward on sustaining operationally capable solutions for platforms. Specifically, providing National Defence with the flexibility required to rapidly integrate the latest technology developed by industry, to ensure platforms remain relevant and capable throughout their lifetime.
    • Shifting from more traditional transactional relationships with industry on in-service support, to a more partnership-focused relationship. This will ensure we work together on setting out capability roadmaps for systems that will need to be continuously updated and integrated on various platforms throughout their lifecycles. This revised process will make sure industry is part of the solution and able to help predict and rectify any obsolescence as the platform progresses, thereby reducing our need for timely modernization or upgrade projects.
  • PSPC-led Risk-Based Approach to Contract Approval enables lower complexity projects to progress through the acquisition process with fewer check points, allowing the overall program to progress towards a timely delivery of projects and capabilities.
  • The Tailored Project Approval Process was implemented in 2017 to provide a flexible and scalable framework for DND to fully leverage its Organizational Project Management Capacity Assessment Level, through improved internal coordination, increased delegation, and strengthened approval processes. Low to Medium Risk Projects that follow the tailored approval process progress on average two to three times quicker.
  • In November 2022, National Defence’s Project Approval Directive was amended regarding the Urgent Operational Requirement process, resulting in significant time savings throughout the Project Phases for those capabilities that are most urgently needed.
  • National Defence works with government and industry partners to optimize defence procurement, including through new initiatives such as Continuous Capability Sustainment (CCS).
    • CCS seeks to identify ongoing investments in technology upgrades over the in-service phase of a capability to ensure CAF equipment remains technologically relevant, fit for purpose, and aligned with the extant high level mandatory requirements.
  • Through its digital transformation initiative, the department will leverage necessary upgrades to its enterprise resource planning function to transform and modernize business processes, improve operational effectiveness and decision support at all levels. Through the increased use of analytics and a heightened trust in the data within the system, the Department will be able to better harness vital data to inform decision making.

Professionalization of Procurement Staff

  • A number of steps have been taken to strengthen the capacity of the procurement specialist workforce (project managers, procurement officers and cost estimators).
    • The Project Manager Competency Development (PMCD) program provides project managers with development and learning opportunities through a defined framework for accreditation. Within project implementation organizations, project managers are matched with projects of an appropriate level of complexity and risk
    • The Competency-Based Project Management Organization seeks to enhance project management as an aspect of organizational culture with the following goals:
      • develop an engaged workforce that demonstrates the desired project management competencies;
      • improve workforce planning to ensure the right people are matched with the right projects;
      • provide an inclusive project management environment, and improve overall delivery of projects. 
    • A Centre for Costing in Defence (CCD) was established within the Assistant Deputy Minister (Finance) to generate life cycle cost estimates for each project as it advances through the project life cycle. The cost estimates are based on the best possible information available at the time, and will evolve as more information in known. The cost estimates are provided to project sponsors and decision makers, who use them to set realistic budgets and make informed decisions.
    • A Purchasing and Supply Group (PG) ‘academy’ has been established which will recruit and develop procurement and materiel management specialist throughout their careers. This academy will encompass several developmental branches.
      • The Fundamental Program (one-year program, PG-01 to PG-02) officially onboarded 11 trainees on September 5th with a second cohort of 20 trainees planned for March 2024.
      • The PG Officer Development Program (PG-02 to PG-04) will recommence in FY 2024-25 after a short program pause which allowed us to update and modernize the program framework.
      • The Supervisor (PG-04 to PG-05) and Management (PG-05 to PG-06) programs are currently early in the planning/development phase.
      • A video library channel is also under development and will support all PG Academy programs. The video library channel will enable wider and more accessible knowledge transfer, professional development, competency development and training.  This first set of videos are expected to release before the end of this fiscal year.

Canadian Surface Combatant (CSC)

  • National Defence is committed to providing the Royal Canadian Navy with next-generation warships, which is why we are procuring 15 Canadian Surface Combatants that will be made in Canada as part of the National Shipbuilding Strategy.
  • We are working with industry to finalize the selected ship design for the Canadian Surface Combatants and anticipate beginning low-rate production in 2024, which includes work to ensure that the shipyard is prepared to begin building the vessels and cut steel. Full-rate production is anticipated for 2025.
  • This project will reinvigorate Canadian shipbuilding by investing in Canadian innovation and supplier development. It will also generate at least 31 billion dollars in GDP, as well as create and sustain more than ten thousand jobs over the next 25 years.
  • This includes job training and apprenticeship opportunities for Indigenous peoples, visible minorities, and underrepresented groups.
  • We will remain transparent as we work with industry to find efficiencies, accelerate project timelines, and update costs as the design progresses.

If pressed on infrastructure investment

  • Shipyard upgrades will enable the production and delivery of CSC ships to meet operational needs at an affordable cost, which will sustain the Royal Canadian Navy’s capacity to meet Canada’s defence and security requirements.
  • Accordingly, the cost of shipyard upgrades is directly linked to the cost of building CSC ships. 
  • The decision to fund the upgrades was supported by a business case that demonstrated the upgrades will result in improvements to the build strategy and processes, with associated improvements to schedule and cost.

If pressed on delays and cost increases

  • While the project budget has not changed, we are assessing potential cost increases, mainly due to delays in the project schedule and higher than forecasted inflation.
  • In Fall 2023, we received an initial cost estimate from Irving Shipbuilding Inc. for the first batch of three ships. The cost estimate is currently being reviewed to better understand risks and savings opportunities associated with the proposal.
  • We continue to make important progress, including preparations to begin low-rate production in 2024 and the continued purchase of long lead acquisition material.

Key Facts

  • Estimated Budget:  $56-60B (Design and Acquisition)
  • Timeline: First delivery in early 2030s
  • PBO 2022 Report Costs:
    • Total Life-Cycle Cost: $306B
      • Development: $4.3B
      • Acquisition: $80.2B
      • Operation & Sustainment: $219.8B
      • Disposal: $1.7B
  • GBA+: CSC ships will include berths, wash places, bathrooms, medical facilities, and off-duty areas that are designed to accommodate all genders and promote privacy.
  • Indigenous Relations: Irving Shipbuilding Inc. is leading initiatives, including job training and apprenticeships for Indigenous Canadians, visible minorities, and underrepresented groups in shipbuilding.

Details

  • The CSC will replace and update the capabilities found in both the retired Iroquois-class destroyers and the Halifax-class frigates. This single class of ship will be capable of meeting multiple threats on the open ocean and the coastal environment.
  • As the future warship of the Royal Canadian Navy (RCN), the CSC must be capable of conducting a full range of military operations in high-threat environments and will upgrade and replace the capabilities of two classes of RCN ships in a single, combat-capable vessel. The new warships will be able to conduct a broad range of tasks, including:
    • Delivering decisive combat power at sea, either independently or as part of a Canadian or international task group;
    • Conducting counter-piracy, counter-terrorism, interdiction and embargo operations for medium intensity operations; and,
    • Delivering humanitarian aid, search and rescue, and law and sovereignty enforcement for regional engagements.

Project Status

  • In February 2019, the Government of Canada selected the CSC design, based on the BAE Systems’ Type 26 Global Combat Ship, to meet the unique operational requirements of the RCN. Irving Shipbuilding contracted Lockheed Martin Canada to provide the design and design team.
  • Canada is now working with Irving Shipbuilding, Lockheed Martin Canada, and their subcontractors to evolve the selected ship design and systems integration. In late 2022 the project progressed from the preliminary design phase into functional design.

Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) Estimates

  • PBO 2022 report: On October 27, 2022, the PBO published a report on the total life cycle cost for the CSC project, projected to be $306B.
  • Total life cycle costs includes costs from the development through to disposal phases of the project. Previous PBO reports focused solely on the cost of the acquisition and development phase.
  • The report estimates the development and acquisition phase to be $84.5 billion (excluding taxes).
  • The estimated increases in cost compared to previous PBO reports is attributed to the increase in consumer price index and updated project production timelines, mitigated by the removal of provincial taxes which had been included in the previous PBO estimate.
  • A costing refresh will be conducted by National Defence before entering the Implementation phase of the project.

Economic Benefits           

  • Construction will occur in Halifax, Nova Scotia at Irving Shipbuilding.
    • More than 10,000 jobs will be created over the 25-year build period.
  • The CSC project will promote growth of key industrial capabilities in Canada by creating investments in innovation, supplier development, and export opportunities with a focus on cyber security and the marine sector.

Infrastructure Investment

  • Irving Shipbuilding (ISI) is expanding and modifying its site and facilities at the Halifax Shipyard and supporting facilities in Dartmouth, including at Woodside Industries and Marine Fabricators.
  • Canada has agreed to provide ISI, with funding, $463M taxes included, for them to make infrastructure improvements at their shipyard to ensure that they have the capability to construct the current CSC design and to meet the delivery schedule to support the RCN.
  • The Halifax Shipyard site expansion will include dredging, marine structures, and rock infill behind the structure creating approximately 13 acres of additional yard space. Within the shipyard, the newly expanded area is not expected to extend farther into the channel than the limits of the floating dry dock that was previously located at Halifax Shipyard. The upgrades are expected to enhance shipyard efficiency, directly contributing to the CSC build and delivery schedule. 
  • Infrastructure enhancements began in 2023 to support the start of CSC construction activities, which are expected to begin in 2024 and conclude by 2050.

Joint Support Ships (JSS)

Includes lines on Interim Auxiliary Oil Tanker Replenishment (iAOR)

  • National Defence is committed to procuring Joint Support Ships that will help defend Canada and contribute to international security by providing crucial at-sea replenishment capabilities.
  • The Joint Support Ships are critical for the future of the Royal Canadian Navy and will serve to increase the range and endurance of our naval fleets.
  • These ships will also have military capabilities, providing our sailors the protection they need when deployed in high-threat environments.
  • Construction is underway with the delivery of the first ship forecasted for late 2025.
  • National Defence continues to closely review timelines as we monitor production efficiency.
  • This project will sustain over 1,000 jobs at the Seaspan shipyard in British Columbia and a total of 3,900 jobs in the broader marine industry.
  • Further, the construction of these ships represents a $2.4 billion investment in the Canadian economy.

If pressed on the MV Asterix

  • The MV Asterix is an interim commercial solution to mitigate the capability gap while the Joint Support Ships are being built.
  • Although the Asterix is fulfilling an immediate need, the ship is not equipped to conduct the full spectrum of military activities required by the Royal Canadian Navy.
  • The period of service of the Asterix was extended to January 2025.

Key Facts

  • Budget: Up to $4.1B
    • The full impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on project costs is still being assessed.
  • Timelines:
    • Joint Support Ship 1: Cut steel: 2018; Planned delivery: 2025
    • Joint Support Ship 2: Cut steel: 2022; Planned delivery: 2027
  • GBA+: The JSS were designed specifically to accommodate a mixed-gender crew by including gender-inclusive toilets, chair heights and sightlines, and private showers and changing areas.

Details

  • In June 2020, a $2.4 billion contract (including taxes) was awarded to Seaspan Vancouver Shipyards to progress with full-rate construction.
  • The two new JSS are intended to replace the Navy’s Auxiliary Oiler Replenishment vessels (AOR). They will provide at-sea support to naval task groups, limited sealift capabilities and support to operations ashore.
  • The JSS are critical to the future of the RCN and constitute a vital and strategic national asset. The presence of replenishment ships increases the range and endurance of a naval task group, permitting it to remain at sea for significant periods of time without returning to port for replenishment.
  • The JSS will provide Canada with a modern, task tailored, globally deployable, naval support capability that can provide support to the ships and aircraft of a naval task group at sea. They will be crewed by CAF personnel.
  • The new JSS will have capabilities such as:
    • Underway support to naval task groups:
      • Re-supply of fuel, ammunition, spare parts and other supplies between ships at sea;
      • Operation and maintenance of helicopters; and
      • Task group medical and dental facilities.
    • Sealift: JSS will be capable of transporting and delivering cargo both in support of task group operations and in support to operations ashore.
    • Support to operations ashore: To meet a range of possibilities in an uncertain future security environment, the JSS will leverage its on-board facilities to support operations ashore, ranging from combat to humanitarian and disaster relief.
    • Support to northern operations: JSS will have an Enhanced Ice capable hull designed to operate in limited Arctic waters and will be able to access the Nanasivik Naval Facility during summer navigation season.

JSS Survival Capabilities

  • Equipped with systems to detect and protect against chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear threats.
  • Equipped with a full range of features and systems that enhance their survivability and allow them to fully integrate with other warships (e.g., a combat management system, multiple defensive weapons systems, an electronic support measures suite, air search radar and dual shafts for enhanced redundancy).

MV Asterix

  • The MV Asterix remains an interim solution to mitigate the capability gap while the Joint Support Ships are being built.
  • The period of service for the Asterix was recently extended to January 2025, however, the contract option periods provide a potential interim capability up to January 2028.

Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) Estimate

  • In November 2020, the PBO released a fiscal analysis of the JSS project in response to a request from the House of Commons Government Operations and Estimates Committee (OGGO).
  • The PBO estimated that the JSS will cost $ 4.1 billion (with taxes) which was in line with National Defence's cost estimate.

Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships (AOPS)

  • National Defence is committed to enhancing and safeguarding Canada’s sovereignty in the North, which is why we are procuring six new Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships, designed to operate in previously inaccessible northern waters.
  • These ships will operate in the Arctic between June and October providing a greater and longer Canadian Armed Forces presence in the North, thereby supporting a range of domestic and international operations.
  • Four of the Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships are already in the water, with the fifth planned for delivery in December 2024.
  • The sixth and final ship is anticipated to be delivered in December 2025.
  • National Defence will continue to advance this project, which supports over 2,000 jobs in the Canadian economy, including in Nova Scotia and within the broader shipbuilding industry.
  • This project is also promoting growth and investment in innovation, supplier development, and export opportunities in Canada’s marine sector.

If pressed on technical issues

  • Technical issues are not unusual during the introduction period of a new capability.
  • Most of the in-service issues are technical in nature and have been addressed.
  • Addressing the remaining issues continues to be a top priority to ensure our ships sail on operations and that our personnel in uniform remain safe.
  • As issues have been resolved and the corrections are being taken into account during the production of all follow-on vessels.

If pressed on who will pay for repair costs

  • A shipbuilder’s Material and Workmanship warranty is in effect for 12 months following a ship’s delivery. To date, the Material and Workmanship warranty has covered $5.3M (excluding taxes) in repair costs.

If pressed on cost increases

  • Ship production is complex and relies on multiple activities, such as forecasted cost and availability of material and labour.
  • While costs did increase – due primarily to the pandemic, inflation, longer lead time in procuring parts and challenges associated with ongoing ship production – cost forecasts have since stabilized.

If pressed on delays for the Nanisivik Naval Facility

  • Infrastructure work in the Arctic poses many challenges, including a harsh climate and isolated work locations.
  • National Defence is also mindful of the need to respect the environment and local communities. For instance, the Royal Canadian Navy have agreed with the Government of Nunavut to not break ice near the facility in order to protect community access to frozen waters and protect wildlife.
  • We are currently finalizing commissioning work at the facility, which will operate as a docking and refueling facility to support the Arctic Offshore Patrol Ships and other government vessels.

Key Facts

  • Budget: Up to $4.98B (excluding taxes)
  • Timeline:
    • July 31, 2020: The first AOPS, HMCS Harry DeWolf, was delivered. 
    • July 15, 2021: The second AOPS, HMCS Margaret Brooke, was delivered.
    • August 15, 2022: Production of the sixth and final ship for the RCN began.
    • September 2, 2022: The third ship, HMCS Max Bernays, was delivered.
    • August 31, 2023: The fourth ship, HMCS William Hall, was delivered.
    • December 2025: Delivery target for the sixth and final ship, the future HMCS Robert Hampton Gray.
  • Indigenous Relations: Each ship will be affiliated with an Inuit region to build strong ties with Arctic Indigenous communities as they operate in and around their territories.
  • GBA+: The AOPS were designed to accommodate a mixed-gender crew:
    • Reduced cabin occupancy to facilitate a mix-gendered crew, create privacy, and promote greater comfort;
    • flexible use spaces will accommodate various spiritual practices and promote welfare and team cohesion; and
    • Integrated Wi-Fi will facilitate crew communications with families back home.

Details

Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships

  • The AOPS will significantly enhance the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) capabilities and presence in the Arctic, better enabling the Royal Canadian Navy (RCN) to assert and uphold Canada’s Arctic sovereignty. The AOPS will also augment Canada’s presence on the Atlantic and Pacific oceans and will conduct a wide variety of operations abroad.
  • The AOPS will be able to operate in up to one meter of first-year ice, which is the ice condition experienced annually in the various waterways of the Canadian Arctic between June and October. Ice capability provided by the AOPS will provide a greater and longer Canadian Armed Forces presence in the Canadian North.
  • This will allow the Royal Canadian Navy (RCN) to have unescorted access to areas of the Arctic that were previously inaccessible.
  • The ships are being built under the National Shipbuilding Strategy (NSS) by Irving Shipbuilding Inc. in Halifax, Nova Scotia.
  • These vessels perform a wide variety of tasks, including:
  • Surveillance operations of Canadian waters;
  • Support of sovereignty operations;
  • Support to international operations;
  • Humanitarian assistance, emergency response and disaster relief;
  • Search and Rescue.

Delivery Timeline:

  • Ship 1, HMCS Harry DeWolf, delivered on: July 31, 2020
  • Ship 2, HMCS Margaret Brooke, delivered on: July 15, 2021
  • Ship 3, HMCS Max Bernays, delivered on: September 2, 2022
  • Ship 4, HMCS William Hall was delivered on: August 31, 2023
  • Ship 5, the future HMCS Frédérick Rolette, anticipated delivery: December 2024
  • Ship 6, the future HMCS Robert Hampton Gray, anticipated delivery: December 2025

Deficiencies and Repairs with the AOPS

  • AOPS is the first new warship built in Canada in the last 20 years. Shipbuilding in general is difficult and when building the first ship in a class, it is expected that there will be issues identified throughout the building process—including after delivery—that require correction.
  • Prior to delivery of HMCS Harry DeWolf, HMCS Margaret Brooke and HMCS Max Bernays, construction deficiencies were identified and documented as part of a rigorous quality assurance program. Both the Government of Canada and the shipbuilder agreed that certain deficiencies could be corrected after delivery.
  • The Royal Canadian Navy works closely with the shipbuilder to resolve these deficiencies while progressing the ships’ trials and operational schedule. In the meantime, appropriate mitigation measures have been put in place where necessary.
  • A Technical Investigation into issues with the Main Diesel Generator (MDG) on the AOPS was finalized in early February 2023. The changes recommended by this investigation are being implemented in ships 1 to 4 and will be incorporated within follow-on ships as appropriate.
  • Ship’s 1 and 2 (HMCS Harry DeWolf and HMCS Margaret Brooke) have completed repairs to their Main Diesel Generators and Central Fresh Water Cooling System. This work was completed in Harry DeWolf in July was completed in Margaret Brooke at the end of August of 2023.
  • Repair work on Ship 3, (HMCS Max Bernays), was completed under the builder warranty.
  • Work on Ship 4 (HMCS William Hall) is now complete and  was recently delivered. Issues identified in-service are being rectified proactively during the construction of new ships, including Ship 4.

Nanisivik Naval Facility

  • In 2007, the Government announced its plan to convert the deep-water port at Nanisivik to a logistics hub, which will operate as a docking and refueling facility for the Royal Canadian Navy and other government vessels and serve to enhance the Navy’s presence in the North.
  • The construction of the Nanisivik Naval Facility in Nunavut is nearing completion. The primary role of the facility will be to refuel the Royal Canadian Navy’s Arctic and Offshore Patrol Ships during the navigable season, while also continuing to provide the Canadian Coast Guard with refueling support and storage capacity for re-supply missions.
  • The Auditor General’s report on Arctic Waters Surveillance noted that the Nanisivik Naval Facility (NNF) would not be equipped with heated fuel tanks, limiting its period of operation to approximately 4 weeks per year.
  • As an Arctic facility, the operational year is usually from early August to as late as October, depending on ice-coverage and temperatures. As long as the waters are navigable and the facility is accessible, the site will be open to ships. There are a number of factors which contribute to the length of the facilities operating season.
  • For example, the NNF requires fuel to be shipped in at the start of the season and removed at the end of the season. The fuel barge cannot typically access NNF until early August because of ice coverage. Depending on the temperatures in late September, fuel may start to thicken as the fuel tanks and lines are not heated, limiting the Navy’s ability to use the fuel. At that time the fuel must be removed from the tanks.
  • National Defence is working on a longer term plan to lengthen the operating season, once success and capabilities have been established with the current model.

Indigenous Relations:

  • Each AOPS will be affiliated with a region of Inuit Nunangat. These affiliations are a long-standing naval tradition and deeply valued by the sailors and the civilian communities.
    • HMCS Harry DeWolf formally affiliated with the Qikiqtani region of Nunavut: May 2019.
    • HMCS Margaret Brooke formally affiliated with the Nunatsiavut region on September 21, 2022 in Hopedale, Labrador.
    • The remaining ships will be affiliated with the following regions in Inuit Nunangat: Kitikmeot; Kivalliq; Nunavik; Inuvialuit.
  • Over the next several years, the six vessels and their crews will build ties with the communities in these regions, founded on mutual respect, during routine operations in Canada’s Northern waters.

Deployments:

  • HMCS Harry DeWolfe was deployed as part of Operation NANOOK-TUUGALIK, which took place from August 8 to September 29 in the Davis Strait.
  • HMCS Harry DeWolf operated with the US Coast Guard Cutter FORWARD en route to the Davis Strait. Harry DeWolf proceeded to Nuuk for a visit 25-26 August and worked with United States Navy maritime assets conducting training in Davis Strait.
  • From 29 August to 11 September Harry DeWolf supported JTFN OP NANOOK NUNAKPUT, conducting presence and surveillance in eastern portion of the North West passage. Some activities will include a visit to Mary River Mine and a community relations stop in Pangnirtung prior to returning to Halifax on 1 Oct.

Victoria-Class Submarine Modernization Project (VISSC)

  • Victoria-class submarines are among Canada’s most strategic assets for conducting surveillance of Canadian, international, and near-Arctic waters.
  • That is why we launched the Victoria-Class Modernization Project - to update the fleet and ensure it remains relevant in an evolving operating environment.
  • The decision to modernize remains the most effective means of ensuring continued submarine operations into the mid-2030s.
  • The Victoria-Class Modernization Project will also support jobs across Canadian shipyards and through the supply chain.
  • This will include the supply chains for equipment, providing opportunities for Canadian small and medium-sized businesses.

If pressed on the Canadian Patrol Submarine project

  • We are in the early stages of defining the operational and capability requirements for a new class of submarines to replace the Victoria-class.
  • We have conducted initial engagements with countries and companies that currently have, or are in the process of building, submarines that meet Canadian requirements.
  • We are examining all options to meet the Navy’s requirements.

Key Facts

  • Budget: Up to $1.0B
  • Timelines:
    • First modernization starting date: 2023
    • First delivery: 2027
    • Final delivery: 2036
  • The Victoria-class Modernization Project involves 16 projects. All of these projects are in either the definition or implementation phase.
  • Economic benefit: This modernization project will benefit Canadian industrial and technological sectors and provide robust economic benefits for Canada.
  • Maintenance and modernization projects will support jobs across Canada both at the shipyards and through the supply chain.

Details

  • Canadian submarines deliver a world-class, force-multiplying deterrent effect as well as an unmatched sovereign defence and security capability.
  • These submarines are capable of covertly monitoring evolving situations at home and abroad.
    • At home, submarines provide critical, sovereign force protection capacity for our sea-based forces when required.
    • Abroad, these submarines can conduct “indications and warnings” and vital joint-targeting information, weapon delivery, or Special Operations Force insertion.
  • Canada purchased four Victoria-class submarines from the British Government in 1998.
  • The first three Victoria-class submarines were accepted into service between 2000 and 2003. The fourth submarine suffered a fire in transit to Canada, which delayed its acceptance into Royal Canadian Navy service until 2015.
  • These submarines are scheduled for end of life in the 2034-2040 timeframe.
  • The decision to modernize remains the most effective means of ensuring continued submarine operations for the Royal Canadian Navy into the 2030s.
  • The Victoria-class Modernization Project will focus primarily on enhancing three distinct capabilities:
    • Habitability – to improve habitability and deployment conditions onboard Victoria-class submarines;
    • Joint Force Capability – position the Victoria-class submarines to contribute meaningfully to joint operations ashore; and,
    • Survivability – to ensure the survivability of the Victoria-class submarines against an evolving complex threat in an ever-changing battle space.

Gender-Based Analysis Plus (GBA+)

  • New equipment will enhance accessibility for crew members, including improvements in both privacy and functionality of:
  • Sleeping areas;
  • Wash places (including gender-neutral washrooms); and
  • Dining/social areas.

Future Fighter Capability Project (FFCP)

Defence of Canada Fighter Infrastructure Program (DCFI)

  • On January 9, 2023, following a rigorous and competitive procurement process, the Government of Canada announced an agreement with the United States Government and Lockheed Martin with Pratt & Whitney for the acquisition of 88 F-35A fighter aircraft.
  • This represents the most significant investment in the Royal Canadian Airforce in more than 30 years.
  • The F-35 will be essential for protecting the safety and security of Canadians, enhancing Arctic sovereignty, allowing Canada to meet its NATO and NORAD obligations, and boost our interoperability with key allies and partners.
  • We are already taking steps towards the acquisition of an initial tranche of aircraft, with the first deliveries anticipated to begin in 2026.
  • In parallel, we have begun the construction of the Fighter Squadron Facilities in Bagotville, QC, and Cold Lake, AB.
  • Construction of these Fighter Squadron Facilities will generate over 900 jobs in the surrounding regions.
  • We are confident this procurement will deliver the capability needed for the Royal Canadian Air Force, while providing high-value economic benefits for Canada's aerospace and defence sector for decades to come.

If pressed on the Parliamentary Budget Officer Report on F-35 Life Cycle Cost

  • National Defence appreciates the important and independent work of the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO), including its recent report on the F-35 procurement.
  • A modern fighter aircraft is critical to protecting North American airspace and meeting defence and security challenges abroad.
  • For National Defence, it is important to hear different points of view, leverage lessons learned, and ensure value for money.
  • We are also always open to exchanging advice with the PBO and parliamentarians to help inform public dialogue on important defence issues.
  • National Defence will remain transparent as we work to validate and update costs as the project continues to progress.

If pressed on Economic Benefits

  • Canada’s participation in the U.S.-led multinational Joint Strike Fighter Program has yielded approximately USD$3.5 billion in contracts for Canadian companies since 1997.
  • Canadian industry will have significant sustainment opportunities on the F-35A fleet.
  • Opportunities are expected in areas such as airframe and engine depots, as well as in training and in maintenance of components over the life of the fleet.
  • Canadian companies were hired also to support the development, design and construction of Fighter Squadron Facilities for the F-35A aircraft at 4 Wing Cold Lake and 3 Wing Bagotville.
  • Today, there are 36 active contractors in Canada, contributing a wide-range of manufacturing and services to the global F-35 fleet.
  • Canadian companies were also hired to support the development, design, and construction of Fighter Squadron Facilities for the F-35A aircraft at 4 Wing Cold Lake, AB, and 3 Wing Bagotville, QC.

If pressed on training RCAF pilots outside of Canada to operate F-35A aircraft

  • As with all major military procurements, careful planning and preparation is required to introduce new equipment into service.
  • This is particularly true for highly advanced weapons systems where, for instance, sophisticated training for pilots and technicians is needed while continuing to conduct daily operations.
  • As such, the initial training of the RCAF pilots and aircraft maintenance technicians will take place in the United States, until a suitable training capability is established in Canada.

Key Facts

  • Project Budget: $19 billion in acquisition funding was established in Strong, Secure, Engaged. This includes the aircraft, associated equipment, sustainment set-up and services, as well as the construction of Fighter Squadron Facilities in Cold Lake, AB, and Bagotville, QC.
  • Procurement: Canada has committed to an initial tranche of 16 F-35A aircraft via the Production, Sustainment, and Follow-on Development Memorandum of Understanding (PSFD MOU).
  • Delivery: The first aircraft will be delivered in 2026. The project will work with the F-35 Joint Program Office (JPO) through the project implementation phase to acquire additional F-35A fighter aircraft along with the associated equipment and services.
  • Initial Pilot Training: The initial  aircraft will be located at the F-35A Pilot Training Center in Luke Air Force Base, Arizona, to enable the training of RCAF pilots while DND builds the necessary infrastructure to support aircraft delivery and commence operations in Canada.
  • Fighter Squadron Facilities: To prepare for the arrival of the aircraft, National Defence will continue the infrastructure work that has begun in Cold Lake, AB, and Bagotville, QC, and begin the construction of the Fighter Squadron Facilities at these locations. These facilities will be home to the operational and training squadrons as well as provide space for some maintenance activities. Construction on both facilities is expected to begin in 2024.
  • GBA+: A GBA+ analysis was conducted for the FFCP, and the project will continue to assess potential differential impacts based on gender and other identity factors. This includes considering GBA+ impacts on equipment/aircraft design and training, as well as design of facilities in Bagotville & Cold Lake.
  • Economic Benefits: Canada’s participation in the Joint Strike Fighter Program MOU has resulted in USD $3.5 billion in contracts awarded to Canadian companies since 1997.
  • Lockheed Martin and Pratt and Whitney have committed to provide economic benefits equal to the contract value over the life of the Joint Strike Fighter Program to be completed within 25 years in Canadian Content Value.
    • This may include contracts to Canadian companies for equipment, parts, and services for the global F-35 aircraft and engine production.
  • Indigenous Relations: The infrastructure design-builders in Bagotville and Cold Lake will prepare benefit plans to support Indigenous procurement objectives.
  • Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) Report: On November 2, 2023, the PBO published its report providing an independent analysis of costs associated with the F-35 procurement. In this report, the PBO estimates acquisition costs to be $19.8 billion and $73.9 billion for the total life-cycle cost.

Details

Project Details

  • The Future Fighter Capability Project (FFCP) will successfully acquire and transition into service 88 advanced fighter aircraft along with the associated equipment, weapons, infrastructure, information technology, and sustainment, including training and software support.
  • The competitive process was led by Public Service and Procurement Canada and was overseen by an independent fairness monitor.
  • In December 2022, the Government of Canada approved the acquisition of the F-35A, as the replacement to the CF-18 fighter aircraft fleet.

Project Timelines

  • December 2017: The Government of Canada launched an open and transparent competition for the permanent replacement of Canada’s fighter aircraft fleet.
  • July 23, 2019: The Government of Canada released the Request for Proposals to eligible suppliers.
  • July 31, 2020: Bids received from eligible suppliers.
  • December 1, 2021: The Government of Canada announced that following evaluation of the proposals submitted, two bidders remained eligible—SAAB (Sweden) and Lockheed Martin (U.S. Government).
  • March 28, 2022: The Government of Canada announced that it would enter into the finalization phase with the top ranked bidder: the U.S. Government and Lockheed Martin, for F-35 fighter jets.
  • January 9, 2023: Canada announced that it had finalized an agreement with U.S. Government and Lockheed Martin with Pratt & Whitney for the acquisition of 88 F-35 fighter jets for the Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF).

Economic Benefits

  • Lockheed Martin and Pratt and Whitney have committed to providing economic benefits equal to the contract value over the life of the Joint Strike Fighter Program, to be completed within 25 years.
  • This may include contracts to Canadian companies for equipment, parts, and services for the global F-35 aircraft and engine production.

Gender-Based Analysis Plus (GBA+)

  • New infrastructure for the F-35A will be designed to take into account GBA+ considerations, including safety and the equitable fairness of infrastructure such as washrooms, sleeping quarters, and cultural spaces. The following GBA+ considerations are being incorporated into the design of the Fighter Squadron Facilities (FSF):
    • A lactation room has been incorporated into the design of the FSF facilities based on DND Policy requirements that a lactation room be made available to CAF personnel;
    • A multi-faith room has been included in the design of the FSF based on the Chaplain Guideline for Canadian Forces Sacred Space;
    • An area for Indigenous Smudging ceremonies has been included in the design of the FSF;
    • The FSF will be accessible for persons with disabilities and to personnel requiring assistance in alignment with Government of Canada requirements for accessibility excluding maintenance and service areas; and
    • Respectful gender inclusive washrooms, showers, and change rooms have been incorporated into the design of the infrastructure based upon consultations with stakeholders.

Indigenous Considerations

  • The requirement for federal departments and agencies to ensure a minimum of 5% of the total value of each and all department and agency contracts are awarded to Indigenous businesses does not apply to FFCP procurement
  • This commitment came into effect after FFCP’s release of its Request for Proposal, during the Proposal evaluation phase. Furthermore, the FFCP procurement is conducted through Government-to-Government Arrangements (MOU and Foreign Military Sales Cases) and is therefore not subject to the set-aside Program for Indigenous Business.
  • However, FFCP has endeavored to find means to directly and indirectly support the Government of Canada’s Indigenous commitments.
  • Specifically, within the FFCP Infrastructure component, proactive engagements are taking place by the Modified-Design Build (MDB) contractors with identified Indigenous communities with the intent that the Indigenous partnerships formed will contribute to mutually beneficial and sustainable economic benefits to the Indigenous communities in the Bagotville and Cold Lake areas.

Joint Strike Fighter Program (JSF) and Production, Sustainment and Follow-on Development (PSFD) MOU

  • The JSF Program is a U.S.-led multinational cooperative effort to build an advanced combat aircraft equipped to fulfill multiple roles.
  • The objectives of the JSF program include: developing, producing, and sustaining the most advanced, affordable fighter for participants; maximizing commonality to achieve affordability and coalition interoperability; implementing a global sustainment system to deliver continuous cost and performance improvements; and promoting industrial involvement for participants.
  • Canada has been an active participant in the JSF Program since it began in 1997, and in 2006 became a partner in the PSFD MOU, which was renewed in 2021. The current PSFD MOU was renewed to December 2051.
  • To date, Canada has spent USD $712.5M to participate in the program. The most recent payment was for USD $99.5M, made on 1 May, 2022.
  • Note: The 2023 payment of USD $97.343M is currently being processed. Once processed, Canada will have spent USD $809.84M to participate in the program. Canada’s participation in the Program provided Canada with the option to buy the aircraft at the lowest possible cost and with priority access to the production line. This provides Canada with production and delivery flexibility, even as the number of Foreign Military Sales customers steadily increase.
  • 8 partner countries are part of the JSF PSFD MOU: Australia, Canada, Denmark, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, United Kingdom, and the U.S.
  • To date, there are 9 foreign military sales customers of the F-35: Belgium, Finland, Germany, Israel, Japan, South Korea, Poland, Singapore, and Switzerland.  

Parliamentary Budget Officer Report

  • On 2 November, the PBO published its report regarding an independent analysis of costs associated with the F-35 procurement. This encompassed costs analyses of the development, acquisition, operations, and sustainment, as well as disposal costs of the project.
  • As part of this study, the PBO conducted an independent life-cycle cost analysis of the announced F-35 procurement; its analysis of costs related to the acquisition phase ($19.8 billion) as well as total life-cycle costs ($73.9 billion) are largely aligned with those previously published by National Defence.
  • Canada’s historical contributions to the Joint Strike Fighter Program MOU (2006) was not included as part of PBO’s costing.
  • In its background section, the PBO report mentions the initial procurement in 2010; noting that, at the time, the Government of Canada announced that it would buy 65 F-35 jets at a cost of $18 billion. This costing was subsequently analysed in follow-on reports published by the PBO (2011) and the Auditor General (2012).

Defence of Canada Fighter Infrastructure

  • The Defence of Canada Fighter Infrastructure Project will ensure the Canadian Armed Forces are ready to receive 88 F-35 fighter jets.
  • This project will design and construct new infrastructure, as well as modernize and recapitalize existing infrastructure.
  • Additionally, upgrades will be made to information management infrastructure, power distribution, and airfield rehabilitation in support of fighter capability.
  • These upgrades will generate regional employment near several Royal Canadian Air Force Wings and Northern locations and continue to be an important part of Canada’s NORAD modernization plan.

Key Facts

  • On March 24, 2023, the Prime Minister announced the Defence of Canada Fighter Infrastructure (DCFI) project will deliver a range of infrastructure elements to support Canada’s new fleet of F-35 fighter jets and Canada’s NORAD contributions.
    • Through the DCFI project, National Defence will invest $7.3 billion to modernize, recapitalize, and build new infrastructure to support the arrival of the F-35 fighter jets and bolster Canada’s ability to project air power in defence of North America for the coming decades.
  • Over its duration, the Defence of Canada Fighter Infrastructure Project (DCFI) project will deliver 33 elements. Each element is an individual piece of infrastructure or upgrade which is grouped into four main categories:
    • operations;
    • logistics;
    • personnel support infrastructure; and
    • enabling infrastructure work.
  • The DCFI project will upgrade airfields, electrical and IM/IT systems, and build hangarettes, Quick Reaction Alert facilities, maintenance facilities, storage warehouses, accommodations, and training facilities to support operations, personnel, and logistics. 
  • The DCFI project is scheduled for Initial Operational Capability in 2029, with Full Operational Capability scheduled by 2032.
  • A majority of the infrastructure investments under the DCFI project will occur at the main fighter operating bases in 4 Wing Cold Lake and 3 Wing Bagotville, but investments will also be made to support fighter operations and deployment across Canada, including at the following Wings and northern locations:
    • 19 Wing Comox,
    • 1 Canadian Air Division Headquarters Winnipeg,
    • 17 Wing Winnipeg,
    • 8 Wing Trenton,
    • 22 Wing North Bay,
    • 14 Wing Greenwood,
    • 5 Wing Goose Bay,
    • Forward Operating Location Yellowknife,
    • Forward Operating Location Inuvik, and
    • Forward Operating Location Iqaluit.

Details

  • On 9 January 2023, the government of Canada announced that it had finalized an agreement with the United States Government and Lockheed Martin to acquire 88 F-35As to replace the Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF)’s CF-18s.
  • Concept work for the Future Fighter Capability Project (FFCP) indicated that the current infrastructure layout and design at Canada’s two main airbases, Cold Lake and Bagotville, is outdated and retains design elements from the 1950s. These facilities are no longer fit-for-purpose and require extensive upgrades to accommodate the future fighter aircraft.
  • In response to both new infrastructure requirements for future fighter capability and legacy infrastructure issues, National Defence established the DCFI project as a distinct endeavour from the FFCP acquisition.
  • The DCFI project was announced by the Prime Minister, during a visit by the President of the United States, on 24 March 2023.
  • This new project builds on earlier infrastructure work that began under FFCP, modernizing or recapitalizing existing infrastructure and adding new critical elements.

Canadian Multi-Mission Aircraft (CMMA)

  • To enable Canada to credibly defend its interests, at home and abroad, the Canadian Armed Forces need to be able to identify, detect, track, and potentially engage advanced surface and sub-surface threats using an array of highly sophisticated sensors.
  • That is why, under Canada’s Defence Policy – Strong, Secure, Engaged (SSE), National Defence committed to acquiring up to 16 P-8A Poseidon aircraft for the Royal Canadian Air Force.
  • This aircraft will replace the aging CP-140 Aurora, which has been in service for more than 40 years, and enable the Canadian Armed Force to sustain a technological advantage over potential adversaries.
  • The P-8A Poseidon will provide the Canadian Armed Forces with a modern long-range, crewed maritime patrol aircraft specialized in anti-submarine and anti-surface warfare.
  • It is optimized for C4ISR -command, control, communication, computers, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance.
  • The Poseidon is the only currently available aircraft that meets all Canadian Multi-Mission Aircraft operational requirements – there is no alternative on the market today.
  • The platform is a proven capability that is operated by several of our defence partners, including all other Five Eyes nations, as well as Norway and Germany.  
  • As a result, Boeing will make targeted investments across Canada, with the potential to create up to 3,000 jobs annually.
  • We will continue to make significant investments to provide the members of our Canadian Armed Forces with the equipment they need to do their jobs and keep them safe.

If pressed on NDDN motion on CMMA procurement process

  • I welcome the Committee’s motion regarding the CMMA procurement process.
  • We are working alongside Public Service and Procurement Canada to develop a comprehensive response to the Committee’s motion.
  • We look forward to providing it to the Committee in due course.

If pressed on a Canadian-made aircraft

  • Canada’s adversaries are deploying increasingly sophisticated, stealthy, and lethal capabilities.
  • At the same time, the CP-140 Aurora is reaching its estimated end of service date of 2030.
  • This procurement will ensure that the Royal Canadian Air Force is able to identify, detect, track, and potentially engage advanced surface and sub-surface threats.
  • A developmental option brings a high degree of risk and uncertainty with regards to cost, schedule and the delivered operational effectiveness.

If pressed on the need to move quickly (the threat)

  • Although Canada’s defence policy was grounded in a thorough assessment of the global security environment as it was understood in 2017, the speed at which our adversaries would evolve their military technology was underestimated.
  • Escalating global challenges have accelerated the operational demand for an effective CMMA capability for Canada and identified the criticality of the operational readiness of this capability, including interoperability with our allies.

If pressed on the options Canada considered

  • As with any procurement, we examined our military requirements and held consultations with industry, in order to determine the best capability for our members and value for money.
  • In the case of the CMMA project, we had multiple engagements with industry, led by PSPC.
  • We consulted Allies throughout the process and will continue to do so leading into transition from the CP-140 to the P-8A Poseidon.
  • These are also lessons that we have learned with ongoing projects.
  • For instance, the Maritime Helicopter Project (MHP) obtained approval in November 2004 and FOC has been progressively delayed to a current estimate of 2024. To date, that represents about 20 years of development on a uniquely Canadian solution.

Key Facts

  • The Canadian Multi-Mission Aircraft (CMMA) will equip the CAF with a long-range manned Command and Control, Communications and Computers (C4) and Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance (ISR) and Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW), and Anti-Surface Warfare (ASuW) aircraft with extended capabilities.
  • On November 30, 2023, the Government of Canada announced its decision to procure between 14 and 16 aircraft specialized in anti-submarine and anti-surface warfare from Boeing through a Foreign Military Sale with the US.

Value of Foreign Military Sale (FMS): $5.1B USD including:

  • 14 aircraft with an option for up to two additional aircraft.
  • Support equipment, technical assistance, training devices, training, and an initial in-service support period.
  • The cost of training aids and simulators is included within the overall project budget and within the FMS case.
  • Canada is assessing the infrastructure needs for the replacement fleet and requirements to recapitalize infrastructure at the operating bases.
  • The aircrafts will be based at 14 Wing Greenwood, N.S. and 19 Wing Comox, B.C.

Timelines:

  • First delivery: 2026.
  • Initial Operational Capability: 2028.
  • Full Operational Capability: 2033.

Economic Benefits: Canada has negotiated meaningful economic benefits for Canadian industry:

  • Boeing will integrate Canadian companies in global supply chains, develop clean technologies and support the development of skills and training in Canada.
  • Boeing’s economic commitments to Canada have the potential to generate more than 3,000 jobs annually and contribute at least $358 million annually to Canada’s gross domestic product over ten years.
  • Boeing will open an innovation centre in Montreal, invest in research centres and develop partnerships with universities across Canada.
  • Furthermore, Canada intends to compete the follow-on in-service support requirements for this capability.

Details

Canadian Multi-Mission Aircraft (CMMA)

  • The CMMA Project will deliver an enhanced long-range, long-endurance, multi-mission capability to replace the CP-140 fleet. It will be specialized in Anti-Submarine and Anti-Surface Warfare and optimized for C4ISR (command, control, communication, computers, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance).
  • On 30 November 2023, Canada announced that it had finalized a government-to-government agreement with the United States (US) government and Boeing for the acquisition of up to 16 P-8A Poseidon aircraft for the Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF). 14 multi-mission aircraft will be procured, with options for up to an additional two, subject to affordability.
  • On whether the U.S. Government’s P-8A Poseidon aircraft has been selected; CMMA project is currently evaluating options:
    • In April 2021, DND launched a third-party CMMA Candidate Aircraft Analysis which identified potential CMMA candidates, their suitability against required CMMA Missions and ranked these potential solutions against High-Level Mandatory Requirements (HLMRs).
    • In February 2022, on behalf of DND, PSPC released a Request for Information (RFI) to validate market analysis conducted by PSPC as part of its role as the Government of Canada procurement authority.
    • The RFI sought input from Industry on High Level Mandatory Requirements (HLMR) and capability requirements pertaining to the replacement of the CP-140 Aurora fleet, including Industry’s interest, capability and experience, which was used to help inform the project’s next step for options available for the replacement of the CP-140 Aurora.
    • Following engagements with industry, Canada’s closest Allies and through independent third-party studies, the government has determined that the P-8A Poseidon is the only currently available aircraft that meets all of the CMMA operational requirements, namely anti-submarine warfare and C4ISR.
    • To explore this option in more detail, in March 2023 Canada submitted a Letter of Request through the United States government’s Foreign Military Sales program outlining Canada’s requirements and requesting an offer.
    • A Letter of Offer and Acceptance was received from the United States government in July 2023 and is currently being reviewed by the project team.
    • PSPC and DND have conducted a review of the LOA and concluded that the capability offered meets all CMMA High Level Mandatory Requirements.
    • ISED is reviewing the Boeing Economic Benefits proposal to ensure the proposal leverages economic benefits for Canada.
    • LOA validity period ends 30 Nov 2023. There is a risk that if the LOA expires, that it would have to be repriced.

Aurora Modernization Project

  • The CP-140 Aurora is Canada’s primary surveillance aircraft.
  • The aircraft is used for multiple types of missions over land and water.
  • This includes long range surveillance and reconnaissance in support of military operations, as well as providing assistance to other government agencies to combat illegal fishing, pollution, and drug trafficking.
  • The strategic capability offered by the aircraft is why we are modernizing the fleet and extending the life of the 14 aircraft to the 2030 timeframe through the Aurora Structural Life Extension Program and Aurora Incremental Modernization Project.
  • Full operational capability for the Aurora Incremental Modernization Project is planned for late 2024.
  • Nevertheless, this aircraft was first procured in 1982 and will be 48 years old upon retirement.
  • Canada’s adversaries are also deploying increasingly sophisticated, stealthy, and lethal capabilities in the surface and subsurface domains, particularly in the last few years.
  • There is a growing imperative to replace the CP-140.
  • To ensure our military has the equipment required to protect Canada’s coastline into the future, the CP-140 Aurora will be replaced with the P-8A Poseidon aircraft.
  • The P-8A Poseidon will equip the Canadian Armed Forces with a long-range, manned maritime patrol aircraft specialized in Anti-Submarine and Anti-Surface Warfare and optimized for C4ISR (command, control, communication, computers, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance).
  • Taken together, the upgrades to the Aurora fleet and future P-8A aircraft will ensure that the Canadian Armed Forces maintains a world-class intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance capability.

Key Facts

  • The Aurora Structural Life Extension Project (ASLEP) involved replacing the wings and horizontal stabilizers on the aircraft. The ASLEP was completed in April 2020 at a cost of $418 million.
  • The Aurora Incremental Modernization Project (AIMP) is integrating new mission systems and sensors onto the aircraft. This project is being executed in a phased approach with four blocks; Blocks I, II and III are complete, and Block IV is in the implementation phase. The AIMP has a project cost of $1.8 billion (including taxes).

Details

  • The modernized CP-140 Aurora Long-Range Maritime Patrol Aircraft is a vital Canadian Joint Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance platform given its cutting-edge anti-submarine warfare and long-range surveillance capabilities. This aircraft is used extensively by the CAF, both in the Arctic and abroad, and is planned to be replaced with the Canadian Multi-Mission Aircraft (CMMA).

Life Extension and Upgrade Work

  • National Defence originally intended to modernize ten aircraft however, in October 2013, an additional $548 million was announced to life-extend and modernize four additional Auroras.
  • The 2013 approval also included definition of three new operational capabilities for all fourteen aircraft (referred to as Block IV) including: 1) a state-of-the-art self-protection system; 2) a Link 16 Data-link system (a military tactical data exchange network used by NATO countries); and 3) a High-bandwidth beyond-line-of-sight satellite communications system. Block IV implementation was approved in June 2015.
  • Timelines for Aurora Incremental Modernization Project (AIMP) Block IV:
    • Initial operational capability (IOC) will be achieved incrementally by capability: IOC for the self-protection system is summer 2023, and IOC for the beyond-line-of-sight satellite communications system and Link 16 is the first quarter of 2024.
    • Project IOC has been delayed several times due to the increased complexity of the design, test and evaluation resource limitations and the requirement to coordinate system certifications with United States Government test agencies. 
    • Full operational capability is planned for late 2024 ;
    • As of August 2023, eight Block IV aircraft are currently in Greenwood, N.S. In addition to operational employment, these aircraft are being used for concept development, training, and ground and flight testing. Three others are undergoing modifications at IMP Aerospace in Halifax, noting that Block IV modifications have yet to be cleared for operational use.
    • Further updates to the CP-140, to be implemented in the next five years, will include: Multi-Fleet Air Traffic Management Avionics updates; Secure Radio Modernization; and Light-Weight Torpedo Upgrade.
  • Concurrent to the Aurora Incremental Modernization Project (AIMP) which focussed on integrating new mission systems and sensors onto the aircraft, the CP-140 also benefitted from the Aurora Structural Life Extension Project (ASLEP) which involved replacing the outer wings and horizontal stabilizers on the aircraft. The ASLEP was completed in April 2020 at a cost of $418 million.  
  • These upgrades will keep the CP-140 operationally relevant and effective until 2030.

Fixed-Wing Search and Rescue

  • The Canadian Armed Forces have effective search and rescue capabilities to keep Canadians safe.
  • Our existing fleets (CC-130H Hercules and CC-130J Hercules) are being used to ensure continued operations while we transition to a new aircraft.
  • We are currently procuring 16 new Fixed-Wing Search and Rescue aircraft (CC-295 Kingfisher) that will enable more effective search and rescue missions in all weather conditions.
  • We have already welcomed 15 of these aircraft and anticipate the initial operational capability of the new fleet in 2025-2026.
  • This project will generate positive economic dividends for the Canadian economy, including by providing highly skilled jobs across the country.
  • For example, Canadian companies are providing many key components on the aircraft, such as the engine (Pratt & Whitney) and infrared vision systems (L3 Harris (Wescam)), which will be integrated into the manufacturer’s broader supply chain.
  • Airbus (the manufacturer) has also developed a joint-venture with Newfoundland and Labrador-based PAL Aerospace to provide in-service support for the Kingfisher aircraft in Canada.
  • We will continue to advance this project and welcome the many jobs and investments it generates for the Canadian economy.

If pressed on delivery delays:

  • We are currently working with the manufacturer to ensure the design and development challenges associated with the integration of the new technical capabilities are addressed.
  • We remain confident that Canada will be provided with an advanced search and rescue capability that will support Canadians for years to come.
  • To ensure life-saving search and rescue services continue uninterrupted, the Canadian Armed Forces will continue to rely on the existing CC-130H Hercules and the CC-130J Hercules, until the CC-295 Kingfisher assumes search-and-rescue operations.
  • The Royal Canadian Air Force does not anticipate any impact to their ability to retain and replace personnel for the CC-130H, CC-130J, CH-149, and CH-146 communities.

Key Facts

  • Contract Value: $2.9B and up to $5.9B (including taxes).
  • Economic Benefit: As part of the Request for Proposal, Airbus is required to reinvest 100% of the contract value into the Canadian economy.
  • GBA Plus: The Fixed-Wing Search and Rescue Training Facility in Comox will include:
    • Gender neutral washrooms that accommodate those with disabilities;
    • Nursing rooms;
    • Cultural rooms for prayer; and
    • All equipment has been designed to accommodate all genders.

Details

The CC-295 Kingfisher aircraft will be able to:

  • Detect, identify, and classify objects and people, in low light and challenging conditions, using state-of-the-art sensors;
  • Communicate better with other search and rescue systems through modern communication, navigation, and data management tools;
  • Conduct searches across the full range of Canada’s search and rescue areas of responsibility; and
  • Be available when needed as a result of robust in-service support, including maintenance, engineering, and training support.

Timeline

  • Ground and flight testing is currently being conducted in Spain, the U.S., and Canada. Five aircraft are located in Comox, BC, and 10 remain in Seville, Spain, in preservation state.
  • Initial aircrew and maintenance training was completed on May 11, 2023.
  • Initial operational capability was anticipated for summer 2022; however, this timeline has shifted to 2025-2026. This delay is attributed to several factors related to the progress of the aircraft’s certification, technical considerations, and training maturity.

Economic Benefits

  • The Industrial and Technological Benefits Policy applies to the FWSAR contract. Bidders were required to partner with a Canadian company to deliver a maintenance and support program that ensured Canadian businesses were involved.
  • Airbus partnered with Newfoundland-based PAL Aerospace, and developed a joint-venture, Airpro SAR Services, that serves as the in-service support Canadian integrator. This approach ensures the majority of the maintenance and support services work is performed in Canada through a network of suppliers under a program managed by Airpro SAR Services.
  • In addition, many of Canada’s leading aerospace and defence companies have been provided opportunities to integrate into the CC295 program for Canada and into Airbus’ broader global supply chain. For example:
    • Pratt & Whitney Canada has provided the engines.
    • L3 Harris (Wescam) the electro optical infrared vision systems.
    • CAE has been subcontracted to deliver the training program and training centre in Comox, British Columbia.
  • This work is providing well-paying jobs for Canadians, growing the economy and supporting a strong Canadian aerospace and defence sector by providing export opportunities for Canadian businesses in global supply chains.

Current Search and Rescue Response Capabilities

  • To ensure ongoing coverage following the retirement of the CC-115 Buffalo, the Canadian Armed Forces will continue to rely on the existing CC-130H Hercules and CC-130J Hercules aircraft until the CC-295 Kingfisher assumes search-and-rescue operations.
  • Trenton Search and Rescue Region (Prairies, Ontario, part of Quebec, Nunavut and the Northwest Territories): FWSAR coverage will continue to be provided by the CC-130H Hercules at 17 Wing Winnipeg and CC-130J Hercules at 8 Wing Trenton.
  • Halifax Search and Rescue Region (North Atlantic to 30W, part of Quebec, part of Baffin Island and Atlantic Province): FWSAR coverage will continue to be provided by the CC-130H Hercules based at 14 Greenwood, NS.
  • Victoria Search and Rescue Region (SRR) (Eastern Pacific Ocean, British Columbia and Yukon Territory): 435 Squadron from Winnipeg delivers FWSAR coverage using a detachment at 19 Wing Comox. The CC-130H Hercules detachment will remain at 19 Wing Comox until the Kingfisher is able to assume SAR operations. Victoria SRR will also have support from CH-149 Cormorant helicopters based out of 442 Squadron in Comox, B.C. For missions at sea, Victoria SRR may also call upon the Royal Canadian Air Force’s 407 Squadron CP-140 Auroras and U.S. Coast Guard fixed-wing aircraft to support the Cormorants, as required.

Remotely Piloted Aircraft Systems (RPAS)

  • National Defence is committed to supporting Arctic security and enhancing our capabilities in the North.
  • For example, we are working to acquire a new long range, high endurance, armed Remotely Piloted Aircraft System.
  • This system will complement existing intelligence and surveillance capabilities and increase our maritime and Arctic domain awareness.
  • Significant development work is required, including modifications to ensure the system can operate at high Northern latitudes and meet Royal Canadian Air Force requirements.
  • This includes the addition of aircraft antennas, communications components, and a Canadian-made sensor.
  • We anticipate contract award by 2024, with delivery of the first system in early 2028.
  • We are also finalizing the associated infrastructure plans, which will result in jobs for Canadians and benefits to our economy.

Key Facts

  • Project Budget: Estimated acquisition cost is $2.49B
  • Current Competition Status: The Request for Proposal was issued in February 2022 to the two qualified suppliers:
    • United States Government and General Atomics Aeronautical Systems, Inc; and,
    • L3 Technologies MAS Inc. (L3 Technologies MAS Inc. subsequently withdrew from the competition in May 2022).
  • Bid evaluation of the two proposals started on August 16, 2022.
  • Economic benefits: The contractor will be required to provide investments in Canadian industry and economic benefits to Canada.
  • GBA+: RPAS facilities will include, in compliance with Directives:
    • Gender neutral bathrooms;
    • Nursing rooms;
    • Cultural rooms for prayer; and,
    • RPAS equipment will accommodate all genders.

Details

Project Details

  • This project will acquire a long range, high endurance, armed Remotely Piloted Aircraft System along with associated equipment, weapons, infrastructure, and in-service sustainment capability that will support up to three concurrent lines of tasking, domestic (including contributing to Canada’s presence in the Arctic) or international.
    • Employment of precision strike capability will adhere to all applicable law, including international laws such as the Law of Armed Conflict.
  • These systems are not autonomous. They are piloted by qualified pilots who control and monitor the aircraft from ground control stations.
  • The Systems will be commanded and controlled in a manner similar to other capabilities, such as fighter aircraft. Qualified and authorized Canadian Armed Forces members will always be responsible for employing these systems.

Project Timelines:

  • November 2020: Draft Request for Proposal issued.
  • February 2022: Final Request for Proposal issued.
  • August 2022: Bid evaluation started.
  • January 30 – February 3, 2023: Cold weather testing validation of proposed solutions was completed.
  • Contract award: by 2024
  • First delivery: early 2028
  • Initial operational capability: fiscal year 2027/28 to 2029/30
  • Full operational capability: fiscal year 2030/31 to 2032/33
  • Project Close: fiscal year 2033/34 to 2034/35

Operating Bases:

  • Aircraft will be stationed at 14 Wing Greenwood, Nova Scotia, and 19 Wing Comox, British Columbia.
  • They will also be operated out of Forward Operating Locations, including in Yellowknife, Northwest Territories.
  • The ground control centre will be located in the Ottawa.

Indigenous Relations:

  • The contract will require that the contractor submit an Indigenous Participation Plan and commit up to 5% of the contract value to support Indigenous participation. Consultation with Indigenous groups will occur to support development of the Indigenous Participation Plans, and for infrastructure design and construction.

Page details

Date modified: